The High Court yesterday dismissed O2`s case against 3 for a series of TV, radio and press advertisements during summer 2004 which compared the companies` pre-pay products. O2 claimed that the price comparison was grossly misleading and that the advertisements infringed its registered trade marks in respect of `O2` and blue bubbles. The Court, found that the ads were a fair and objective price comparison which did not take unfair advantage of or denigrate O2’s trademarks or brand; and that 02 had failed to establish that the use of the bubbles had caused it any economic loss or detriment.The Court did rule that O2’s bubbles were sufficiently distinctive to be registered as trademarks, dismissing a counter-claim from 3 which challenged the validity of the bubble trademarks, but stated that 3 was entitled to use the graphics under the European Comparative Advertising Directive. 02 are considering appealing.