Information Overlord

Literature, Law, Librarianship and More

  • Adoption
  • Books
  • Law & Legal
  • Libraries & KM
  • Media & Broadcasting
  • Politics
  • Telecoms
You are here: Home / Uncategorized / You say CD quality I say – encouragement to illegal download

You say CD quality I say – encouragement to illegal download

5th April 2005 by Scott

I currently have a subscription to Napster uk, and decided to buy/downlaod a couple of albums over the weekend, just because I hadn’t really done so before – the albums for those of you who are interested were: Jem – ‘Finally Woken’ , and Aslyn – ‘Lemon Love’

Now if you follow the links you’ll see that I could buy these from Amazon for £8.99 and £10.99. On Napster both were £7.79 each. So, even with the free postage from Amazon, that’s a saving of £5.30.

Only, is it really a saving? For that ‘extra’ money I am getting the original high quality sound CD, with all the original artwork etc that I am not getting with the downloads.

What I am getting with the downloads is 128kbps

Now MP3 (and alternatives) at 128 kbps is sometimes referred to as CD-quality. But anyone who refers to 128 kbps as CD-quality either has poor hearing; has never done a side-by-side comparison; or has a lousy stereo system and is just playing music through the PC’s soundcard. Whilst I may want to store my music on my PC, when I want to burn it to listen to it on a decent sound system I don’t want 128 kbps. It does NOT sound the same.

I know that it all depends on the encoding to a degree, and on that topic I notice the wikipedia has a page packed full of info on this, but personally I would say you needed to be at 256 kbps to be on a par with CD quality, but that 192 kbps was acceptable.

As a result I have already re-downloaded ‘illegally’ – yes on a p2p network – the Jem that I downloaded/bought legally on Napster to get better quality to burn to CD at 192 kbps [this made me smile as if you buy the Jem CD normally in the UK , you might have problems getting it onto your PC as it includes DRM anti-copying technology that is intended to prevent unlawful copying of the CD with a PC].

I guess my point is, at the current price and bit rate, I don’t think downloading albums legally from Napster (or indeed anyone else) is worth while for any music lover with a decent sound system.

  1. On average price, most albums are only about £1-£1-50 cheaper than buying them in a tradition music outlet or online (and I think that’s more than worth it for the original artwork etc alone). – And with no overheads there is still NO reason why it should not still be MUCH MUCH cheaper to download albums, and we’re atlking £5 and under here.
  2. the download sound quality is just not at a high enough bit rate.

My advice, continue to buy stuff normally where you can,and if not …

Filed Under: Uncategorized

Archives

Categories

Copyright © 2026 · Magazine Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in