Last Friday Judge Victor Marreo, Southern District of New York, struck down an entire Patriot Act provision that gives the government unchecked authority to issue “National Security Letters ” to obtain sensitive customer records from Internet Service Providers and other businesses without judicial oversight. The court found provisions of the Act violate the Fourth Amendment by preventing a challenge to government search and seizure, and the First Amendment because the non-disclosure provision amounts to “unconstitutional prior restraint” on free speech. The Government is expected to appeal.
Great to see the Courts bloodying John Ashcroft’s nose over this insidious piece of misnamed legislation. As in the UK and sadly other coutries too, the terrible events of 9/11 have been expolited to erode long established civil liberties, and waterdown democracy in the name of our protection. A case in point is the UK’s Law Lord’s this week started hearing an appeal for the release of 9 foreign terror suspects (our Guantanamo) who have been held without charge for almost 3 years. One of the barristers for the detainees put it best when he said “Despite the complexity of some submissions in this case, the ultimate issue is really very straightforward.” He said that while it was unacceptable to lock up potentially innocent people without trial, it was “doubly unacceptable for a democracy committed to the principles of equality and anti-discrimination to single out foreign nationals when it is not prepared to apply the same measures to its own nationals”. [Independent]
Meanwhile fellow New York Judge Judge Harold Baer said the anti-bootlegging statute enacted by Congress in 1994 and used to indict a New York record shop owner, who had been selling bootleg recordings of concerts in his shop, was unconstitutional, as the law did not set a timeframe on how long the works would be copyrighted for. Copyright law covers a work for life of the author plus 70 years, but the 1994 act, passed as part of the General Agreements on Tariffs and Trade, “grants seemingly perpetual protection to live musical performances” without ever setting a limit on the protection afforded.
(Haven’t found transcript yet, but should appear here eventually)
[Thanks Technobiblio for pointer to this story]