Some interesting posts on copyright and fair use by judge Richard Posner on Larry Lessig’s site this week.
Interestingly he mentions an article that he and Bill Patry, have written for the California Law Review in which they advocate the same type of reading of fair use as Larry has tounced on in his books “We argue that it should be considered fair use to copy an old work if the copyright owner hasn’t taken reasonable steps to provide notice of his continued rights, as by entering his name and address in a copyright registry. Given such a rule, such registries (which have counterparts in the case of works of visual art) would spring up overnight. Then if an Eldred wanted to publish some old work, he would consult the registry or registries and if no owner was listed (which would usually be the case, because most old works have no commercial value and so their owners won’t bother to try to keep them from falling into the public domain), he could publish it without a license”.
Sounds like a very good idea to me. There seems little logic in the mad extended copyright protection given to many works that could happily be in the public domain. An approach such as this would help restore the balance that the US congress has tried to destroy, and other countries, such as the UK may well follow.