The Independent has an article this morning by Louise Jury called ‘That’s not all right, says music business as first rock classic goes out of copyright’
The article is about the UK music industries push to get music copyrights extended, preferably to US standards of 95 years, as opposed to 50 years across Europe, a fact described as “a quirk of European copyright law” by Jury who tells us ” BMG has only months to capitalise on the re-release of “That’s All Right” (Elvis) before it falls into the public domain on 1 January 2005. Italso tells us that the Beatles’s ‘Love me do’ will folow on 1 January 2013 (yes, still well over 8 years away, and that most of the beatles’ back catalogue will follow from then to 2021.
The point? According to the BPI’s Peter Jamieson “British recording companies were often competing with America, and having less favourable copyright terms put them at a commercial disadvantage. But it was also unfair to performers and record label investors that they would fail to get a return because of a free-for-all in Europe” How is getting a 50 year return ‘unfair’?
According to Mr Jamieson ‘real threat to the British recording industry was “when we get this wealth of British repertoire which started in around 1960 falling into anybody’s hands“. Anybody’s hands? That’ll be you and I the general public then. No doubt we’re not to be trusted with the responsibility of taking care of these assets. Indeed we are told that “EMI finds more of his recordings being exploited as more and more songs come out of copyright”
The labels argue (no remember to shed a tear now) that ‘they invested in the artists originally and their capacity to continue to invest in new talent is often dependent on the income generated by their back catalogue’.
Jamieson says he is confident the Industry can get the Government onside, even if Europe looks less inclined, because “they don’t have the richness of sound recordings that we do.”
Indeed just last week the European Commission launched a consultation on simplifying and harmonising the various existing EU directives on copyright and related rights. The working paper outlining the suggestions resists arguments for wholesale changes to the directives such as extending copyright for recorded music from 50 to 95 years (as in the US), noting that most other industrialised countries apply a term of 50 years.