Information Overlord

Literature, Law, Librarianship and More

  • Adoption
  • Books
  • Law & Legal
  • Libraries & KM
  • Media & Broadcasting
  • Politics
  • Telecoms
You are here: Home / Uncategorized / Go ahead, read my email

Go ahead, read my email

2nd July 2004 by Scott

The 1st Circuit Court of Appeals upheld a Massachusetts court’s decision to throw out a case against Bradford Councilman, formerly vice president of online bookseller Interloc (now part of Alibris) for intercepting and reading the emails of customers for commercial purposes. Interloc provided some of its customers, typically dealers of rare or used books, with e-mail addresses ending in “@interloc.com.” Councilman allegedly ordered the creation of a Procmail script, designed to intercept, copy, and store, all incoming messages from Amazon.com ( sent to those specialty book dealers) before they were delivered to the members’ e-mail, and therefore, before the e-mail was read by the intended recipient, in hopes of gaining commercial intelligence. (Procmail is a popular Unix utility used for sorting and delivering incoming e-mail.)

The majority ruled that “No intercept occurred in this case, and therefore, the Wiretap Act could not be violated,” because federal wiretap laws draw a sharp distinction between intercepting communications that are in transit – such as a telephone call- and those that are stored, even temporarily. As the emails were stored in RAM memory of interlocs computers the e-mails were in electronic storage and that, therefore, the Wiretap Act could not be violated because the requisite “interception” was lacking, according to the Court.

Councilman in his defence stated that he was doing nothing that junk e-mail filtering that employers, schools and other institutions regularly implement, whilst failing to note that these entities do this with the knowledge and permission of their users.

Judge Kermit Victor Lipez in his dissenting opinion stated that the ruling, and the approach of his colleagues to the Wiretap Act “would undo decades of practice and precedent regarding the scope of the Wiretap Act and would essentially render the Act irrelevant to the protection of wire and electronic privacy.”

Demonstrating an understanding to the nature of the internet lacking from his colleagues he rightly points out that email is regularly ‘in storage’ as it moves from the sender to the recipient. “All digital transmissions must be stored in RAM or on hard drives while they are being processed by computers during transmission. Every computer that forwards the packets that comprise an e-mail message must store those packets in memory while it reads their addresses, and every digital switch that makes up the telecommunications network through which the packets travel between computers must also store the packets while they are being routed across the network. Since this type of storage is a fundamental part of the transmission process, attempting to separate all storage from transmission makes no sense.

Congress, probably didn’t intend to define “electronic communication” so narrowly, Lipez warned that the majority’s approach could let the government intercept all communications without having to get the permissions they currently need. Currently, to implement wiretap orders on email accounts, the FBI has to rely on communication service providers to conduct the acquisitions. This decision essential means they no longer have to. The Courts narrow interpretation of the Act, would effectively mean the Government would no longer need to obtain a court authorized wiretap order to conduct such surveillance. “Such a change would not, however, be limited to the interception of e-mails. Under Councilman’s approach, the government would be free to intercept all wire and electronic communications that are in temporary electronic storage without having to comply with the Wiretap Act’s procedural protections. That means that the Government could install taps at telephone company switching stations to monitor phone conversations that are temporarily “stored” in electronic routers during transmission”

Most commentators would argue that the wiretap law, which (whilst it has been amended) dates to 1968, is out of step with technological advances. Privacy advocates fear the decision could set a ‘snooping’ precedent, putting the privacy of email, phone calls and Voice over IP calls in jeopardy. Google’s plans to electronically scan messages sent through its new Gmail service in order to link advertising to message content, look positively innocent compaired to what was going on in this case.

Expect an appeal or an attempt to get the Supreme Court to look at the case.

Filed Under: Uncategorized

Archives

Categories

Copyright © 2026 · Magazine Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in