Information Overlord

Literature, Law, Librarianship and More

  • Adoption
  • Books
  • Law & Legal
  • Libraries & KM
  • Media & Broadcasting
  • Politics
  • Telecoms
You are here: Home / Uncategorized / COPA decison expected this week

COPA decison expected this week

27th June 2004 by Scott

The Supreme Court is expected to issue its decision on the constitutionality of the Child Online Protection Act 1998 (COPA), in ACLU v Ashcroft, some time this week. The Act was the US government’s second attempt on protecting children online. The Communications Decency Act (CDA) 1996 had been their first attempt, which was struck down by the Supreme Court finding in ACLU v Reno 1997 that the CDA’s “indecent” and “patently offensive” provision abridged freedom of speech as protected by the first amendment. The COPA didn’t fair much better with the courts, with the courts blocking Congress from enforcing it.

The Act set out to restrict access by those under eighteen to ‘harmful material’ that was contained on ‘commercial websites’. As in the case of Case of the CDA ‘community standards’ would be one of the tests that ‘harmful material’ was measured by.

In February 1999, judge Lowell Reed Jnr barred the enforcement of the Act, stating that the new law was so unconstitutionally broad that it would invariably affect non-pornographic websites too. In June 2000, the Third U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, upheld this position in no uncertain terms stating:” To avoid liability under COPA, affected web publishers would either need to severely censor their publications or implement an age or credit card verification system, whereby, any material that might be deemed harmful by the most puritan of communities in any state is shielded behind such a verification system…COPA essentially requires that every web publisher, subject to the statute, abide by the most restrictive and conservative state’s ‘community standards’ in order to avoid criminal liability.”

When the Supreme Court first heard the case in May 2000, it declined to rule on many of the key legal issues, instead sending the case back to the lower court to study the legislations meaning. It did reject the claim that the use of ‘contemporary community standards’ as and of themselves as a means to identify ‘harmful material’ rendered the statute overly broad; but its refusal to declare the statute constitutional, or to remove the bar on its enforcement, seemed to indicate that it did feel the lower court was correct to find the law unconstitutional.

When the Third U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals re-examined the case in 2003, it reached an even more scathing conclusion, issuing a permanent injunction, and stating that COPA suffers from multiple, incurable flaws. The Court said COPA “is not narrowly tailored to proscribe commercial pornographers and their ilk, as the Government contends, but instead prohibits a wide range of protected expression”.

The Court found the Act fails the strict scrutiny test (not being narrowly tailored enough to achieve its stated goals): Its definition of ‘material that is harmful to minors’, which includes the concept of taking ‘as a whole’ material designed to appeal to the ‘prurient interest’ of minors and material (when judged as a whole) lacks ‘serious literary’ or other ‘value’ for minors; the definition of ‘commercial purposes’, which limits the reach of the statute to persons ‘engaged in business’ (broadly defined) of making communications of material that is harmful to minors; and the ‘affirmative defenses’ available to publishers, which require the technological screening of users for the purpose of age verification.

The Court argued that in deciding what material was ‘harmful to minors’ the plain meaning of COPA’s text “ mandates evaluation of an exhibit on the internet in isolation, rather than in context … one sexual image, which COPA may proscribe as harmful material, might not be deemed to appeal to the prurient interest of minors if it were to be viewed in the context of an entire collection of Renaissance artwork”

On the issue of ‘for commercial purposes’, the Court stated that whilst congress was obviously thinking of sites that charge for access or sell material, a personal website, whose content is available for free, but who allows paid advertising to appear on their site to cover the costs of maintaining the site, would also be caught by COPA. The Government had argued that as the phrase ‘regular course’ of business was used this would not be the case. The Court disagreed saying the phrase ‘regular course’ does not narrow the scope of speech covered because it does not place any limitations on the amount, or the proportion, of a web publisher’s posted content that constitutes such material. What about a site that primarily publishes general medical information, the Court asked, but that also publishes a regular column devoted to sexual matters that could be deemed ‘harmful to minors’. Under COPA that site would be subject to criminal liability.

Finally on the issue of ‘affirmative defense’, the court ruled that all this approach succeeded in doing was preventing adults from legally accessing web content.

So why is the court looking at COPA again? CIPA: The Children’s Internet Protection Act 2000. In June last year, the Court surprised many by ruling that forcing Libraries to install filters on ALL their computers if they excepted government funding (through the e-rate program) was a legitimate method of protecting children online. This win for the government gave it new hope that the court would now look favourably on COPA. But will it?

In filing the appeal in mid-August 2003, US Solicitor General Theodore Olson said that the use of filter / blocking technology mandated under CIPA was not enough to protect children from the scourge of online pornography. He said children are ‘unprotected from the harmful effects of the enormous amount of pornography on the world wide web’ and that COPA, if enforced, would add to their protection. This same backed up his claim with hard fact: He told the Supreme Court whilst presenting oral evidence that he typed the words “free porn” into an Internet search engine on his home computer and got a list of more than 6 million Web sites, and that was one of his better arguments. Olson argues that the cases of CIPA and COPA are similar, whereas opponents, such as the ACLU correctly point out that this is not the case as COPA can impose criminal penalties for adults exercising constitutional free speech rights (COPA imposes criminal and civil penalties of up to $50,000 per day for violations)

In the CIPA ruling, close reading showed that Judge Rehnquist’s ‘majority’ decision was only supported by 4 of the 9 justice’s (even though the overall verdict was 6-3). It seems certain that the court will be split again, but that the court is still more likely to reject the government’s attempts to enforce COPA, simply due to the fact that the content on the vast majority of those 6 million websites mentioned at the start of this piece is constitutionally protected free speech that US adults have a right to see. It’s time for the final nail to be put in COPA’s coffin, let’s hope the Judges know how to handle a hammer

Filed Under: Uncategorized

Archives

Categories

Copyright © 2026 · Magazine Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in