Yesterday, the EU Parliament adopted an own-initiative report on the 1995 Data Protection Directive by 439 votes in favour, 39 against and 28 abstentions.
The report did not think the directive should be amended – for the time being – except with relation to approval of third country adequacy (see below), but was rightly very scathing of the manner in with the Commission had dealt with some of the key data protection issues related to the directive.
Key findings/Comments:
Data Transfers to Third Countries
Welcomes the intention of the Commission to simplify the regulatory framework for enterprises as regards requirements for international transfers of data.
Stresses that no exception should be allowed to the principle that first-pillar-related data can be transferred to third countries and organisations only if their level of data protection is similar to that of the EU.
States that EU data protection standards are seriously infringed when personal data is transferred or accessed by a third state or law enforcement authority – esp. when data is collected for another purpose and “without judicial authorisation, as in the case of US authorities accessing transatlantic passenger data collected in the EU by airline companies and electronic reservation systems…European laws on the transfer of personal data to third countries have been flagrantly breached by the transfer of transatlantic passengers’ personal data to the US law-enforcement authorities, and whereas the Commission, the Member States and some privacy protection authorities – particularly those which under national law have the power to block data transfers – have substantially colluded in infringing the legislation and the principle of legality”. Agrees with Art. 29 Working party that latest version of undertakings “totally inadequate”
Calls for Directive to be amended to require parliament’s approval for any assessment of adequacy provided by third countries or bodies.
Data Retention
Believes member state laws on data retention do not comply with Human rights law. Asks Commission to produce document on right to privacy and the conditions for exception to be legal, on the basis of the European Convention on Human Rights.
Comprehensive DP Regime
Criticises Commission over serious delays in bringing forward a legal instrument on the protection of privacy in the third pillar (police and judicial cooperation in criminal matters), which should be harmonised with current EU DP law.
Implementation
Highly critical of member states’ implementation of DP directive and recent Communication privacy directive, and the fact the Commission have had to take legal action against states to get action.
Biometrics
Concerned at approach taken by Council to incorporate biometric data in visas and passports.
Will be interesting to see if the Commission actually pays any attention to this, especially as in the issues surrounding data retention and airline passenger data, anyone with even a basic grasp of EU data protection law can see they are indeed being flagrantly breached.