U.S. Chief District Judge John Coughenour, of the Western District of Washington, ruled on Tuesday that he would instruct a jury in Microsoft Corp. v. Lindows.com Inc., to consider whether the ‘Windows’ mark was generic in November 1985 when Microsoft Windows 1.0 entered the market, NOT on its “usage and the understanding of present day consumers” as argued by Microsoft’s lawyers. Lindows.com attorney Daniel Harris, a partner at Clifford Chance said: “People forget there were all these windows systems out there in the 1980s,” Harris said. Now, “after $1.2 billion in advertising,” people think of Microsoft when they hear the word. With this ruling, the trial that was scheduled on March 1, 2004 will not go ahead as Microsoft will now appeal the Court’s ruling to the US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit. Whether the case proceeds will depend on the outcome of that appeal. It’s time to close this window.