The ISPA, the body that represents UK ISPs, has announced the shortlists for the 2004 ISPA Awards. Whilst the goal of the awards it to name best consumer and business ISPs, what most people each year are really interested in are the Hero and Villain’ s awards.
Up in the ‘hero’ category: Law Commission for England & Wales – “for calling for a change to the law relating to defamation on the internet” Steve Linford and Spamhaus – “for educating people about spam, endeavouring to thwart spammers and urging the US to reject the opt-out approach to spam legislation ” Mary Tait from the Department of Trade and Industry – “for maintaining a balanced approach and striving for a joined-up approach to the variety of issues affecting the Internet industry in the E-Commerce Directive, the new Data Protection Directive and Communications Act.” Richard Thomas and the Office of the Information Commissioner – “for demonstrating a pragmatic and user-friendly approach, not just paying lip service to such a goal.” Rt. Hon. Stephen Timms MP – “for the enthusiasm he demonstrates in his role” . All worthy winners, but my vote would be for either Steve Linford, or Richard Thomas.
Up for the ‘Villain’ award are: Broadband Stakeholders’ Group (BSG) “for being beset by a minority of interests, achieving little with their Government funding and not appropriately representing the true broadband industry”; The Home Office “for the Anti-Terrorism, Crime and Security Act and demonstrating a lack of responsiveness to the internet industry’s concerns about data retention.” Recording Industry Association of America “For threatening to involve a 12 year old girl in a court action” Derek Wyatt MP – “for lowering level of informed debate on the internet generally and spam in particular” and Verisign “for their presumption that they own the internet and the domain name system hijacking scandal” . Again, all VERY worthy winners although I’d just give it to the RIAA for sheer persistence, edging out the UK Home Office and Verisign.
The Internet Service Providers Association will announce the winners of the 2004 ISPAs on 19 February.