I came across an interesting ISP liabilty case ruling this week. The High Court has dismissed claims against BT, AOL, and Tiscali for liability for allegedly defamatory postings made by their customers.
Mr John Bunt, the Claimant, was seeking remedies against six defendants – Mr David Tilley, Mr Paul Hancox, and Mr Christopher Stevens (who took no part in the current proceedings) and their respective ISPs, AOL, Tiscali and BT because they published the offending words “via the services provided” by their ISPs.
Bunt who claims he and his business have been defamed on multiple occasions on comments left on his website and on usenet bulletin boards, believes that the ISPs a equally to blame in what he describes as “a truly vast case, the like of which English Defamation Law has never before seen, because of both the scope and nature, as well as the medium. It positively screams out for a Trial, and one way or another it will have one.”
Bunt relied on the Godfrey v. Demon Internet case to argue that the court could hold the ISPs liable.
The Court did not agree with Mr Bunt, and rejected his view that this issue “can only be settled by a trial”, stating “it is a question of law which can be determined without resolving contested issues of fact”.
The Court dismissed Bunt’s claims under Defamation Act 1996, the Electronic Commerce (EC Directive) Regulations 2002, and the Harassment Act 1997, finding “there is no realistic prospect of the Claimant being able to establish that any of the corporate Defendants, in any meaningful sense, knowingly participated in the relevant publications. His own pleaded case is defective in this respect in any event. More generally, I am also prepared to hold as a matter of law that an ISP which performs no more than a passive role in facilitating postings on the internet cannot be deemed to be a publisher at common law” .
He did however caution that that “if a person knowingly permits another to communicate information which is defamatory, when there would be an opportunity to prevent the publication, there would seem to be no reason in principle why liability should not accrue.”
The Court said that Bunts claims, and therefore his remedies lie against the first to third Defendants in the case and his ability to establish the necessary ingredients in respect of each
The case against the remaining 3 defendants >in the AOL,Tiscali, BT libel case (Myself >David Tilley, Chris Stevens and Paul Hancox)>brought by John Bunt was struck out as an >abuse of process by Judge J Griggs at Exeter>court on 27 July 2006.>>Judge Griggs commented that while Bunt>could probably issue further actions that>the 3 defendants would almost certainly >have cause for a counter claim. >>Costs for the 3 defendants are to be >applied for.>>David Tilley dcjtee@aol.com