This weeks issue of the Lawyer has an article by Graham Simkin and Kevin Smith of Fulbright & Jaworski on the potential liability for service providers – such as YouTube and MySpace for hosting infringing copyright material, posted by users on their sites. It looks at the section 512 defence in the US and the UK’s electronic commerce regulations, which both offer some exception to service providers from liability and concludes that until they are tested in court, the question of whether or not service providers would be protected by these pieces of legislation is open to debate
In both instances the authors think that wo central questions arise. “First, is it reasonable for the service providers to be able to rely on the exclusions while undoubtedly benefiting from the use of copyright material? Second, is it unreasonable to impose on copyright owners an obligation to sift through the millions of items being transmitted daily in order to identify specific examples of copyright infringement?”
Well worth a read.