Anna Zelenka has an interesting article entitled why instant messaging is better for collaboration than email.
“In instant messaging, the default mode is one-to-one, not one-to-many. It’s not about covering your butt or showing how much you know, but getting to the point. With email it’s all too easy to add yet another person to the conversation, and in the process drag down productivity while decreasing people’s willingness to share ideas”
In an ideal world this is no doubt very true, but in reality I am not sure giving everyone where I work access to IM would result in people getting to the point any quicker. In truth most people would use IM as a way to talk to their friends at work about what was on the TV last night etc. Not that I think this is a bad thing or a reason to dismiss IM – after all it is not as if most people are not already using the email system for these conversations already – and putting pressure on the email systems in doing so.
That said, there is no doubt that in large email conversations and even in face to face group meetings that people can be either unwilling or feel unable to share ideas. Often people will go with the flow and allow the views of the most forceful to dictate, resulting in possible ideas that themselves may provide solutions, or may spark another idea that leads to a solution, not getting heard. Obviously there are numerous ways of addressing these problems, but there is no doubt that IM is one avenue where initial ideas can be germinated and discussed ahead of such meetings.
From a brainstorming standpoint the argument for email is of course a no brainer, as no one in the right mind is going to use email as a brainstorming tool
My own view is that different methods work for different situations, and for different people, and that going forward the work place should offer workers a variety of tools to choose from to enable them to achieve their goals, be they email, IM, wiki, blogs, forums … and let’s not forgot that old fashion thing called the phone too. One size does not, and should not, fit all.