Information Overlord

Literature, Law, Librarianship and More

  • Adoption
  • Books
  • Law & Legal
  • Libraries & KM
  • Media & Broadcasting
  • Politics
  • Telecoms
You are here: Home / Uncategorized / ASK … don't strum

ASK … don't strum

8th December 2006 by Scott

An interesting domain name case was decided the other week, which I have just picked up.

ASK! has managed to get the ask.eu transferred to it. The eu Arbitration Panel has overturned the decision by .eu Registry (Eurid) to award the ask.eu domain to First Internet Technology Limited (FIT).

FIT got a Benelux trade mark registration for the word ASK for guitar plectrums. However, they claimed their business was actually an Internet services company which provides web hosting and internet advertising services. Coincidentally they had also registered 46 other marks generally consisting of an English word for which the associated goods and services are generally plectrums; all of which were applied for on 22 November 2005.

IAC accused FIT of being a company set up for the purpose of warehousing domain names that are likely to be of interest to brand owners, solely for the purpose of selling those domain names to the brand owners at a premium price; of filing the ASK Benelux Mark purely for the purpose of its application for the disputed domain name; and of trying to sell the domain to them through a third party. The Panel agreed.

The Panel said it was ‘stretching credulity beyond breaking point’ to believed FIT was genuinely to protect promotional items – the Plectrums – in the Benelux territories only. They found it more likely that FIT registered this and 46 other marks (consisting of an English word for which the associated goods and services are generally plectrums; all of which were applied for on 22 November 2005) purely to support speculative applications for certain domain names under the phased registration period. Consequently, the Panel did not accept that FIT has made demonstrable preparations to use the disputed domain name in connection with the offering of goods and services and found that the disputed domain name was registered without legitimate interest.

The panel also found that it was hard to believe that FIT was not aware of the third party offering to sell the domain to IAC, and that it failed to address the question of why the disputed domain name was pointed to the website of the ASK!, an action that can only have been undertaken by the them or on its behalf. As a result the Panel found that the disputed domain name was both registered and used in bad faith, and order the domain to be transferred to ASK!

Filed Under: Uncategorized

Archives

Categories

Copyright © 2026 · Magazine Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in