Andrew Gower has totally agreed with CIPIL report stating that argument for a term extension are ‘unconvincing’ and that the European Commission (and the UK) should retain the length of protection on sound recordings and performers’ rights at 50 years. Additionally it recommend that policy makers (Mr Blair, Mr Brown, he’s talking to you) should adopt the principle that the term and scope of protection for IP rights should not be altered retrospectively.
The report makes some cracking points, non more so than to Recording industries often dragged out argument that the UK is disadvantaged by not having the same protection as offered in the US.
“In the EU, the term of protection for sound recordings and performers’ rights is harmonised at 50 years. During this period, rights holders receive royalties for almost all public performances of their work. In the USA, the term of protection is 95 years, but under the Bars and Grills Exception around 70 per cent of eating and drinking establishments, and 45 per cent of shops, do not have to pay royalties to performers. In the USA, performers only receive royalty payments when their music is played on digital radio, while in the UK all radio performances carry royalties. If the system in the USA was the same as that in the EU, estimates suggest that European rights holders would receive royalties of $25.5 million per annum for the broadcasting of their recordings in the USA. It is therefore possible that the total royalties received in the EU is no less than, and may even be more than, those received in the USA”.
The need of an extension in copyright to incentivise creativity was also given short-shift by the report which said “Economic evidence indicates that the length of protection for copyright works already far exceeds the incentives required to invest in new works. Boldrin and Levine estimate that the optimal length of copyright is at most seven years”
They went on to quote from the rather wise Thomas Babington Macaulay MP from 1841 “it is good that authors should be remunerated; and the least exceptionable way of remunerating them is by a monopoly. Yet monopoly is an evil. For the sake of the good we must submit to the evil; but the evil ought not to last a day longer than is necessary for the purpose of securing the good”, and the from Dave Rowntree, drummer with Blur and The Ailerons, commented on the same point “I have never heard of a single one [band] deciding not to record a song because it will fall out of copyright in ‘only’ fifty years. The idea is laughable”.
Hard to argue with that as far as I am concerned (although I suspect the music industry will do so anyway. Expect toys to be thrown out of pram, and much lobbying to follow). Of course the government can ignore all the recommendations made here. Speaking of which, this issue wasn’t all the review was about. Other highlights/proposals include:
- introducing a limited private copying exception, which will allow consumers to format shift legitimately purchased content, for example music from a CD to an MP3 player. This will allow consumers to use copyright protected material in a manner which does not damage the interests of rights holders;
- clarifying the research exception. This will create greater scope for research on protected material by universities and business and expand the stock of knowledge;
- enabling libraries to copy and format shift master copies of archival works. This will prevent valuable cultural artefacts from deteriorating because they exist only on outdated formats.
- proposing an ‘orphan works’ provision to the European Commission. This will make it easier for creative artists to re-use ‘orphan’ copyright protected material (for which no author can be found), thus unlocking previously unusable material;
- consulting to enable fast-track litigation to be used in IP cases. This should mean that capped fees, limited disclosure and time limits will apply to IP cases, greatly reducing the cost;
- supporting the establishment of a unitary Community Patent (COMPAT). This will substantially reduce the cost of patent applications in Europe, which are currently twice as expensive as in the USA;
- matching penalties in the physical and digital world for IP infringement. This will remove the current unjustifiable anomaly whereby infringement in the d igital world carries softer penalties than infringement in the physical world. This is particularly important given that so much infringement now occurs via digital media;
- consulting to ensure that an effective and dissuasive system of damages exists for civil IP cases. This will provide an effective deterrent to IP infringement; and
- giving Trading Standards the power and duty to enforce copyright infringement. This will ensure that preventing the sale of copyright infringing goods, for example counterfeit CDs, will become a duty of Trading Standards agencies throughout the country.