A Group of telecoms, IT, and associated businesses including AT&T, Dell, Sony and the Computer and Communications Industry Association have issued a statement asking WIPO to redraft their proposed treaty on the protection of broadcasts and broadcasting organisations, as they believe passing the treaty in its current form would do economic and public policy harm. The group recommends that if the plans for the treaty go ahead then a signal-based approach should be taken and not the misguided and unnecessary rights-based approach which creates broad new intellectual property rights in order to protect signals. In addition they believe the treaty should: include a provision excluding coverage of fixations, transmissions or retransmission across a home or personal network; (ii) that the technological protection measure provisions are inappropriate and should be excluded;(iii)that network intermediaries should be exempted from liability for alleged infringements of rights; and (iv) that the treaty should not in its current form be applied to the internet.
It is good to see the group make this statement as there is no doubt that in its current form the treaty expands the protection for broadcasters is at the apparent cost to all others – original copyright holders and consumers. And the change of wording in the new treaty from ‘right’ (in the Rome Convention) to ‘exclusive rights’ would give broadcasters control over content – even if that was content that was public domain, and signatories would have to prevent other circumventing these ‘exclusive rights’
Let’s hope WIPO listen.