As I’d hoped Susan Crawford had now posted on the decision, and as expected makes a lot of sense. In particular she identifies how in this decision and in what ICANN was requiring ICM to do, ICANN was entering dangerous territory of specifying the use rather than registration of a domain:
“Policies as to the use of domain names, as opposed to the registration of domain names, are not appropriate subjects for ICANN decisionmaking. By keeping such a short leash on ICM’s development of its policy organization, which will in turn make decisions about the use of names at the second level, ICANN may be getting into dangerous territory. We should not run the risk of turning ICANN into a convenient chokepoint for the content-related limitations desired by particular governments around the world. Governments have many powers within their territories, and are free to use them there.”