The Conservative party’s Economic Competitiveness Policy Group has launched its report entitled Freeing Britain to compete. The document seeks to set out plans by the party to cut red tape and help business. Unsurprisingly, it calls for tax cuts and less regulation and a repeal or serious amendment of legislation which the party feels is harming the UK, particularly in the workplace, such as Working Time Regulations, the Health and Safety at Work Act, and Employment Tribunals Act.
The latter is: “skewed in favour of employees who challenge their employers because the former do not suffer any monetary consequences for filing frivolous cases. Businesses are therefore left vulnerable to exploitation, and must often cover their own legal expenses resulting from the case. This decreases efficiency as unproductive workers are retained for fear of legal action (particularly affecting smaller businesses).”
Would these be the same employees that are virtually making themselves unemployable afterwards – win or loose – as (rightly or wrongly) many employers will look at employees who have done this as being potential trouble makers?
Of interest from this usual perspective of this blog, is the inclusion of the Data Protection Act 1998 as one of the pieces of legislation identified as needing repeal, consolidation or significant amendment. According to the report this is an ‘expensive bureaucracy, which fails to protect people’s data. The ever growing power of the internet and computers means we all end up on ever more lists, whether we want to or not. Proper handling of the data given to public bodies and private sector companies would be governed by the general law of privacy, and by established codes of conduct’.
In an accompanying working paper, included in the report, they add ‘we strongly suspect that it would be possible to reform the Act in order to reduce its burden. We are also concerned that the Act as currently drafted may limit the ability of government departments to share innocuous data in order to reduce the administrative burden’.
Yes, changes are needed, but mainly to give the Information Commissioner more powers to prosecute and dish out ‘real’ fines to those who take the piss when it comes to data protection.
The report also questions the need for sector specific regulators where competition and other laws are adequate to manage the sectors.’ The aim should be to remove the remaining barriers to competition in all these markets, and then to abolish the special regulators’ (such as Ofcom for example). It also questions the government’s involvement in the markets, for example calling the auction of spectrum for 3G services ‘the imposition of a £22 billion tax on the telecoms industry, just when it needed all the cash it could generate in order to build new networks and compete in a global market’.
Ah, hindsight. Wonderful thing.
Elsewhere, they repeat their, welcome, position of being against the National ID Card scheme claiming it ‘will cost billions of pounds, and add needlessly to myriad existing forms of identification such as passports, driving licences, NHS cards, and other benefit entitlement cards’. No argument on that one.
On the issue of consumer contracts they propose two changes: Carrying out a feasibility study into how a plain English “responsibility” warning could be incorporated into consumer contracts, warning consumers that they are responsible for their own actions and requiring them to acknowledge this in some way (e.g. by signing); and examining the merits of having a new “regulatory court” serving retail consumers (akin to the small claims court) should be assessed, as part of a feasibility study of responsibility warnings.
On the subject of the BBC they propose ‘considering splitting off the commercial activities of the BBC from its public sector broadcasting duties and responsibilities more clearly than at present, and wish to ensure that the financing of such activities is entirely within the private sector, with no recourse to licence payers’ money in the event of mistakes being made. The BBC should not be allowed to advertise its commercial services on public service channels that do not take adverts from other commercial concerns’.
There are some ok suggestions in the document – less pointless SI’s and less legislation in general (as the current government is obsessed with passing legislation), for example, but much of it could have been lifted from Tory policy of 20 years ago.