Information Overlord

Literature, Law, Librarianship and More

  • Adoption
  • Books
  • Law & Legal
  • Libraries & KM
  • Media & Broadcasting
  • Politics
  • Telecoms
You are here: Home / Uncategorized / ASA Watch

ASA Watch

1st March 2006 by Scott

In this week’s ASA bag we have …

The Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) has upheld complaints against ads on TV and in an Argos Catalogue for Top Up TV, which included the text ‘Channels are broadcast at Top Up TV specific times’ . The ASA ruled that it did not believe that most viewers would understand the statement ‘Channels are broadcast at Top Up TV specific times’ to mean that the channels would be shown for less time overall and that some programmes, which were available on other platforms, would therefore be missing from the Top Up TV schedule. Top Up TV argued that other Channels such as BBC 3 and BBC4 also ran at specific times, and that other Channels such as Discovery Kids were also broadcast by different platforms at their own specific times which was not explained in their advertising. The ASA dismissed both of these arguments as Channels such as BBC3 were free to air and did not start or end mid-programme; and Channels such as Discovery Kids broadcast on other platforms were one channel of many, whereas all Top Up TV’s channels were shown for less time than on other platforms. The ASA also upheld a complaint that the text in the Argos Catalogue which outlined the times of the Channels was too small to read.

The ASA advised the Broadcast Advertising Clearance Centre (BACC) and Top Up TV that they would need to make the particular characteristics to the service sufficiently clear and prominent in all future advertising to avoid further action in view of the three previous adverse adjudications on the issue since 2004 – (i) In September 2005 the ASA upheld complaints against Top Up TV (and Argos again) for advertisements for Top Up TV that did not make clear the maximum number of channels that could be viewed at any time on the service, and the fact that viewing times were restricted so that a channel could cut out mid-programme; (ii) In January 2005 the ASA upheld complaints that a catalogue advertisement and leaflet issued by (yes, you’ve guessed it) Argos and Top Up TV for a set top box was misleading. The ASA considered that the phase “a small one off connection fee” misleadingly implied customers would have to pay the connection fee only once, even if they stopped paying for the service for a period of time. The ASA also noted that the leaflet and advertisement did not state the cost of the connection fee; and (iii) in July 2004 Ofcom upheld complaints against Top Up TV, for a misleading advertisement that claimed to “boost your current channel line-up with ten of the most popular digital channels”, but which would only give viewers a choice of 5 channels at any one time (reduced to two in the early hours of the morning).

And there’s more …

The ASA has upheld complaints against Tesco Global Ltd t/a Just-Dial for a poster for an international telecoms service for a calling card which would allow cheap international calls from a mobile phone, such a 1p per minute to Australia. The ASA accepted that Tesco had accidentally omitted information in the footnote of the poster, but found it was misleading as it was not possible to use the calling card without incurring extra charges to the advertised pence per minute call costs. The ASA also upheld complaints against Vectone Bangla, for the repeating of a live programme which displayed premium rate numbers for viewers to call to bid on items without any indication that the programme was a repeat and that the items could already have been sold; and the NSPCC for a mailing in the style of a child’s birthday card aimed at highlighting the issue of paedophilia which was not clearly identifiable as a marketing communication, and could therefore mislead recipients into believing it was personal correspondence. And one to make the Government happy, the ASA dismissed complaints against Switchco t/a Digital UK for a radio Ad announcing the coming of digital switchover deciding the Ad was not misleading in relation to there not being a cost involved by including the phrase ‘going digital doesn’t have to be expensive’. I expect to see a few of these complaints over the next year or so.

Filed Under: Uncategorized

Comments

  1. Paid Survey says

    5th March 2006 at 7:46 am

    some birtday gifts ideas and cards for you:< HREF="http://www.whatarethey.com/free_birthday_cards.html" REL="nofollow">http://www.whatarethey.com/free_birthday_cards.html<>

Archives

Categories

Copyright © 2026 · Magazine Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in