Information Overlord

Literature, Law, Librarianship and More

  • Adoption
  • Books
  • Law & Legal
  • Libraries & KM
  • Media & Broadcasting
  • Politics
  • Telecoms
You are here: Home / Uncategorized / RIPA Conviction Upheld

RIPA Conviction Upheld

3rd February 2006 by Scott

Clifford Stanford, the ex Demon Internet boss has had he appeal against his conviction for unlawful and unauthorised interception of electronic mail communications to a public company contrary to the Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act (RIPA) 2000 dismissed.

Stanford, who founded Demon Internet in 1992 and sold it in 1998 to Scottish Telecom for £66m (Scottish Telecom subsequently re-branded as Thus) was sentenced to six months imprisonment, suspended for two years for admitting to unlawfully intercepting emails at his former company, Redbus Interhouse in September last year.

Stanford had hired George Liddell, to gather information about John Porter, son of Dame Shirley Porter and former chairman of Redbus, after the two men fell out. Stanford, who resigned from Redbus in 2002, had hoped to win control of the company by forcing Porter to resign from the board.

However, the exchange of emails between mother and son also proved that Dame Shirley had more money than she had previously admitted, and are believed to have “triggered” her decision to settle the multi-million pound “homes-for-votes” charge made against her. The “homes for votes” scandal of the 1980s, was a scheme whereby council homes in Westminster were sold to potential Conservative party voters. She was hit by a surcharge of £37m after an inquiry into the affair, but insisted that her assets only totalled a few hundred thousand pounds.

The emails proved differently.

The facts that Stanford had sought to advance at trial were that an employee of Redbus had been granted administrator access to usernames and passwords of the email server, and had set up a mirroring rule whereby emails of particular members of Redbus would be automatically copied to a separate email server accessible by him and Stanford. According to Stanford that employee had been lawfully given those usernames and passwords by a senior member of staff . It was Stanford’s case that this employee, through the senior member of staff’s authorisation, had been placed in a position to control the use of the system he was a person with a right to control the operation or use of the system under s.1(6)(a) of RIPA which reads:

The circumstances in which a person makes an interception a communication in the course of its transmission by means of a private telecommunication system” if either: (a) he is a person with a right to control the operation or the use of the system; or (b) he has the express or implied consent of such a person to make the interception.

Stanford tried to argue that trial Judge Geoffrey Rivlin’s interpretation of s.1(6)(a) was wrong because the effect of the judge’s ruling was to criminalise Lidell even though the username and password Lidell had been given gave him the ability to control the operation and use of the system and also the right to do so, since they had been knowingly given without any restrictions upon use.

The Appeal Court held that judge Rivlin had been “correct to hold that ‘control’ meant ‘authorise or forbid’. That accorded with the verbal context in which control was set and produced a sensible result. The ‘right to control the operation or use of the system’, as provided by s.1(6)(a), was wider than the right to operate or use the system. The concept of control in this context extended to controlling how the system was used and operated by others. Further, the objective of s.1 was to protect the privacy of private telecommunications, and it would have undermined that objective if anyone with unrestricted ability to operate and use a telecommunications system was exempt from criminal liability for intercepting communications. Accordingly, the judge’s ruling was plainly correct and permission to appeal was refused.”

Filed Under: Uncategorized

Archives

Categories

Copyright © 2026 · Magazine Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in