Information Overlord

Literature, Law, Librarianship and More

  • Adoption
  • Books
  • Law & Legal
  • Libraries & KM
  • Media & Broadcasting
  • Politics
  • Telecoms
You are here: Home / Uncategorized / US gets ready to ‘protect children’ again

US gets ready to ‘protect children’ again

20th January 2006 by Scott

The Bush administration, seeking to revive its COPA (Child Online Protection Act) case has apparently subpoenaed Google for details of 1 million random Web addresses and records of all Google searches from any one-week period, to help them show that the law, which was correctly struck down by the Supreme Court, is the least restrictive means of protecting children from obscenity online. The Supreme Court said filters may be a more effective solution in combating child pornography and remanded the case back to the District court in Pennsylvania for trial.

Thus far, Google has refused to comply with the subpoena, which was issued last year. Yahoo, and MSN which received a similar subpoenas, have admitted to handing over the data (minus any personally identifiable information)

The Bush administration certainly fancy their chances in this case. The Supreme’s only ruled 5-4 in favour of ruling the law unconstitutional. Also instead of ending the case once and for all they gave the Bush administration another bit of the cherry by sending it back to the lower court. As Justice Breyer (in a dissenting opinon) said at the time “If this statute does not pass the Court’s ‘less restrictive alternative’ test, what does? If nothing does, then the Court should say so clearly”.

This still seems a valid point; if the Court felt filters are less restrictive than COPA – which the majority clearly did, why send the case back to the District court once again? The Court said that the parties may “introduce further evidence” as to the “relative restrictiveness and effectiveness of alternatives to the statute”. It remains hard to disagree with Justice Breyer when he said, “I do not understand what that new evidence might consist of”.

There may be an update on how blocking / filtering software has moved on since the case started, but can there really be anything else?

What will the Google records show? (or the Yahoo and MSN data for that matter). Since what seems to have been requested is random anonymised data, so that you will not know WHO was visiting a certain site – let alone their age – will this really tell us, or the court, anything other than that people use the internet to search for a lot of porn? Er, Hello. Do we really need the search engine’s information to tell us this?

Filed Under: Uncategorized

Archives

Categories

Copyright © 2026 · Magazine Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in