Circle-ID has a good piece by Milton Mueller on the fiasco that is the .XXX domain name approval process. Now I have already nailed my colours to the mast in this debate and said that granting of approval to the domain was a mistake, and that the domain is not needed and will not help protect people from porn on the internet. That said, this article deals with another point that I agree with, which is the obvious governmental interference with ICANN in this process. ICANN gave approval to the domain in June 2005 and entered into commercial and technical negotiations with ICM Registry, Inc to give the domain the full go ahead. As far as we can tell there are no problems with these details, just problems with the US Government and others belatedly (as public opinion changes) complaining about the domain for which they were originally in favour.