The House of Lords had its Second Reading of the Bill on Monday. A good quality debate with some great contributions from both side of the argument. HOme Office Minister, Baroness Scotland kicked things off helping informing everyone just what the bill sets out to achieve “first and formost to provide individuals with a convenient method of proving their identity”
The Government’s reading is once again at odds with others reading of the Bill. In his lastest criticism of the Bill, Information Commissioner, Richard Thomas wrote
” The primary aim of the Government with this legislation should be to establish a scheme which allows people to reliably identify themselves rather than one which enhances its ability to identify and record what its citizens do in their lives.”
In a wondeful comment, typical of the thinking of Richard Thomas, he says “Robust measures for issuing cards and linking these to particular individuals are essential. The government proposes substantial powers to require information from individuals and other sources to check identity and to record biometric features to tie a card to an individual. However, once this process is complete and the ‘gold standard’ established, there can be little justification for retention of all such details in a central National Identity Register”.
You could just stop there, frankly. I could go on for pages more picking out lots more from the actual debate, but will save you the pain, and just highlight a few additional points raised.
Baroness Walmsley raised an interesting point with regards children. She pointed out that the accepted definition of a child in the uk was someone under 18, but that under the bill anyone 16 and over would need to have a card, and the bill gives the Secretary of State powers to lower that age to any age he or she chooses. ” When a child is forced to submit to the collection of personal data and does not consent to the sharing of that data, that is a breach of Article 16 of the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child and article 8 of the ECHR ..” This is a good point and not one that I think has been addressed before.
The Earl of Erroll came out with a couple of spakling comments first saying that “the old refrain ‘everyone else has one [ID Cards], so I want one too’ makes us sound like a spoilt child”
He went on to point out that despite government claims that with an ID Card you could open a bank account, that under the anti-money laundering rules, you would still need proof of address, otherwise a drivers licence could be used now. [Also the post’s title is how he refered the the National Identity Register]
Apart from that, the usual themes of general civil liberties, the change of relationship between citizen and state, the Government’s cost figures, its repeating of misleading figures – esp on the level of ID Fraud, and once again the government’s refusal to admit that the ICAO is only requesting an international standard for a biometric pasport and that only a digitised version of the biometric is required to be stored on the passport.
The Bill now goes to Committee stage and third reading. It is expected that the Lords will defeat the bill sending it back to the Commons, where the Government will be forced to abandon it or force it through.