I haven’t mentioned this for a while, so to bore those who have been lucky to miss previous posts on the topic … The UK Government’s ID Card Bill once again made it through the House of Commons last week, although the Government’s majority was slashed to just 25. The Bill now goes to the House of Lords were it is likely to be voted down once again, leaving the Government to decide whether to force the bill through, or abandon it.
The Bill, which is enabling legislation, one were the government get to fill in the details later. There remains little actual detail beyond providing for 61 separate powers to enable the Home Secretary or his successor to produce secondary legislation (61 Statutory Instruments).
The Government remains committed to the idea of the Card being a cure all. According to Home Secretary Charles Clarke “First, ID cards will help to tackle identity fraud, which now costs the UK economy and society more than £1.3 billion a year. Secondly, a secure identity system will help to prevent terrorist activity, more than a third of which makes use of false identities. Thirdly, identity cards will make it far easier to control immigration and illegal working, and British citizens will be able to use their identity cards instead of a passport to travel in Europe. Fourthly, ID cards will secure the more efficient and effective provision of public services. The scheme will not create threats to privacy or change the way we live our lives, as many have alleged. We have never proposed a scheme under which it would be compulsory to carry a card or which would require the production of an identity card to the police.”
The Government continues to claim that the scheme is “voluntary” and would not hold detailed personal information. In the current version, it would not be compulsory to buy or carry ID. However, the Government has stated that its end goal is that ID Cards be made compulsory, and the Bill leaves open that possibility. In the mean time the Government aims to go about making the voluntary card sound rather compulsory anyway.
Anyone wanting to get a new passport from 2008 onwards (or another designated document – Drivers licence, Criminal Records Bureau check – and the government leaves open the option to add to this list) “must” include an application to be entered on the ID register. True they do not have to have the card then, but have to do everything else that’s need for the card. A person could obviously refuse, but refusal would mean not passport, no drivers licence etc.
John Gummer commented “we are changing fundamentally the attitude towards passports. The passport is not a privilege offered by the Government to citizens. It is a right of citizens to get the support of their Government when travelling abroad. If the Government insist that we cannot have that right without compulsorily entering into something else, it is the first example of a change in the relationship between Government and subject. This is not an easy thing to bring about; it is a fundamental change to what the passport means. Inside our passports, there is a promise by the Government to do all that they can to enable me or any passport holder who is a British subject to move round the world unhindered. However, it will now become a privilege offered by the Government to such people as will sign up”.
The cost of the database also worries many. The NHS database went from £6.2 billion up to £20 billion. The probation service database went from £85 million to £120 million, and was then scrapped. The air traffic control system went from £350 million to £630 million. Why would the database for ID cards be any different they ask? The Government does not seem to be offering any guarantees that this database, which would be largest in Europe, will come in on budget.
The Government was not helped by Microsoft, who broke ranks this week when Jerry Fishenden, a top security and identity management expert at Microsoft, said that the British government’s current technology proposals are flawed. Fishenden said no systems are ever completely secure and warned that putting vast amounts of personal data and biometric information such as iris, fingerprint and facial scans in one central database could prove too tempting a target for hackers and other criminals. He also criticised other technology suppliers for failing to speak out publicly about their concerns, voiced in private, for fear of damaging any future bids for part of the lucrative contract for ID cards.
Today the Huuse of Lords’ Constitution Committee published a report where they re-iterate their view that contray to the government’s statements to the opposite, that the ‘constitutional significance of the Bill is that it adjusts the fundamental relationship between the individual and the state’.
The Committee argue that overseeing the ID Register should not be in that hands of the secretary of state and rebuff Baroness Scotland’s assertion that it shoud be a direct responsibility of governmen, as is the issuing of passports and drivers licences, by pointing out that passports and the information on them are issued under royal prerogative and are not covered by statute law. In addition in both these cases people are not obliged to apply for either a drivers licence or a passport.
The committee also call for amendments to the Bill to make the ID scheme commissioner independent of government, and allow it to handle complaints, as well as further amending the bill to ensure that if a move was made towards the cards being compulsory that primary legislation has to be introduced at that point to do so.