Information Overlord

Literature, Law, Librarianship and More

  • Adoption
  • Books
  • Law & Legal
  • Libraries & KM
  • Media & Broadcasting
  • Politics
  • Telecoms
You are here: Home / Uncategorized / Google Print

Google Print

21st September 2005 by Scott

The Authors Guild, along with a former US poet laureate, Daniel Hoffman, is suing Google for copyright infringement, for its book scanning Google Print project.

The latest issue of E-Commerce Law and Policy has a well constructed article by US lawyer, Jonathan Band, on why copyright concerns relating to Goggle’s Print Project are unfounded. Band uses the Kelly v Arriba decision to argue that the Ninth Circuit courts line of thinking in that case, and their finding the search engine’s – Arriba – actions compatible with fair use, would apply in a similar way to Google.

Under the Print Library Project, Google plans to scan material from the libraries of places such as Harvard and Oxford Universities, and the New York Public Library. Once completed, web searchers will be able to browse the full text of any public domain materials, but only a few sentences of text around the search term in books still covered by copyright.

The one issue you cannot side step is that Google is going to copy entire books, which under I suspect all copyright law is going to be infringement without permission from the copyright holder. As Seth Finkelstein has said on the topic if Google’s stance is “Let us make e-books of all library content, and keep them – for copyright reasons we’ll only display search results”. That’s clearly very dubious under copyright.

Band argues ” In the Print Library Project, Google’s copying of entire books into its database is reasonable for the purpose of the effective operation of the search engine; searches of partial text necessarily would lead to incomplete results. Moreover, unlike Arriba, Google will not provide users with a copy of the entire work, but only with a few sentences surrounding the search term. And if a particular term appears many times in the book, the search engine will allow the user to view only three instances – thereby preventing the user from accessing too much of the book”

Band goes on to say that whilst Google will operate the program for commercial purposes, “it is not attempting to profit from the sale of a copy of any of the books scanned into its database, and thus its use is not highly exploitative”. Not sure I really buy this particular argument
Band then goes on the compare things to the normal everyday function of search engines, and argues that what google is doing here is no different for the concept of implied license used by search engines to make copies of website content for their cache etc. As he says, this implied license theory has not yet been tested in court.

Dr. Karl-Friedrich Lenz (in his always entertaining blog) is certainly someone who would argree that the the issue with Google Print and search engines are no different. Lenz thinks users should have to opt-in to be included in normal search engine searches, not choose to opt-out.

It will be interesting to see if the Authors Guild case makes it to court. One to watch.

Filed Under: Uncategorized

Archives

Categories

Copyright © 2026 · Magazine Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in