An interesting appeal decision was published today in raltion to premium rate services here in the uk. The Independent Appeals Body has reduced a record fine of £230,000 imposed by ICSTIS, the UK premium rate services regulator, on PRS Communications to £100,000, ruling that ICSTIS had exercised its discretion incorrectly, as the fines were disproportionate compared with previous ICSTIS fines.
However, the IAB dismissed the argument made by PRS that the maximum fine ICSTIS could impose under it’s Code of Practice, and powers given it under the Communications Act 2003 was limited to £100,000. The IAB stated that Ofcom’s interpretation of section 123 of the Communications Act placing a cap of £100,000 per case was a mistaken interpretation of the Act, and that the fine of up to £100,000 referred to the maximum fine for each ‘contravention’ of the code not to a case as a whole.
As a result the decision to reduce the fine in this case does not preclude ICSTIS from imposing fines in excess of £100,000 on operators in the future providing the breaches are sufficiently serious.
Interesting reading. The decision which – with minor exceptions – confirmed all the breaches identified by the original ICSTIS panel is a welcome one, and provides ICSTIS with some real teeth going forward in tackling abuses of the PRNs. It should also act as a wake up call to PRN service operators, that contraventions of the code can be dealt with very seriously.