The Supreme Court has ruled unanimously that software companies who take “affirmative steps to foster infringement.”may violate federal copyright law when they provide computer users with the means to share music and movie files downloaded from the Internet
The opinion of the court issued by Justice David Souter, said: “We hold that one who distributes a device with the object of promoting its use to infringe copyright, as shown by clear expression or other affirmative steps taken to foster infringement, is liable for the resulting acts of infringement by third parties”
The Court argued that Grokster and Streamcast are far from the passive parties they claim to be. The Court said there was abundant evidence that both companies had specifically targeted Napster users when that company was under threat of closer. A kit developed by StreamCast to be delivered to advertisers, for example, contained press articles about StreamCast’s potential to capture former Napster users. An internal e-mail from a company executive stated: “We have put this network in place so that when Napster pulls the plug on their free service… or if the Court orders them shut down prior to that… we will be positioned to capture the flood of their 32 million users that will be actively looking for an alternative” The Court said it was clear that both companies targeted their products as Napster users in a manner that said you can get everything – illegal downloads – you can on Napster with us. There was also evidence to show that Streamcast executives monitored the numbers of songs by certain artists on their network to ensure that they had a larger number of copyrighted songs on their network than any other p2p offering. The Court also pointed to both companies failure or willingness to utilise filtering solutions to dimish infringing activity by their software users.
“This evidence alone would not justify an inference of unlawful intent, but viewed in the context of the entire record its import is clear”, Souter states “The unlawful objective is unmistakable”.
He argued that the case for imposing indirect liability in this case is “a powerful one”, due to the number of infringing downloads committed using the two companies software each day, and the court implied that the result of infringement at this level makes in difficult or impossible to target all the direct infringers, so going after the distributor of the copying device for secondary liability on a theory of contributory or vicarious infringement is the best way forward.
On closer reading there is a question of just whether the court actually has found the Defendants liable or not. The end of Judge Souter’s opinion states: “If liability for inducing infringement is ultimately found, it will not be on the basis of presuming or imputing fault, but from inferring a patently illegal objective from statements and actions showing what that objective was. There is substantial evidence in MGM’s favour on all elements of inducement, and summary judgment in favour of Grokster and StreamCast was error. On remand, reconsideration of MGM’s motion for summary judgment will be in order. The judgment of the Court of Appeals is vacated, and the case is remanded for further proceedings consistent with this opinion. This seems to indicate that depending on the particular evidence, the defendants could be liable”.
The Court seems to have quite happily avoided making any comment on the limit of the Sony doctrine?, instead just holding that the Ninth Circuit overstated Sony’s protection, saying its judgement rested on an “erroneous understanding” of Sony, reading it “as limiting secondary liability quite beyond the circumstances to which the case applied” The Court argues that the Ninth Circuit read Sony’s limitation to mean that “whenever a product is capable of substantial lawful use, the producer can never be held contributory liable for third parties infringing use of it; it read the rule as being this broad, even when an actual purpose to cause infringing use is shown by evidence independent of design and distribution of the product, unless the distributors had .specific knowledge of infringement at a time at which they contributed to the infringement, and failed to act upon that information”.
There was however some disagreement in the decision on this. In his concurring opinion Justice Breyer, joined by Justices Stevens and O’Connor argued that the whilst concurring with the overall opinion of the Court, that the Ninth Circuit’s reading of the Sony was not in error and that relevant aspects of it should be upheld. MGM argued that evidence that only 10% of files downloaded using the Defendant’s software are legal is not a high enough percentage to be found to be a ‘substantial’ non infringing use. Beyer points out that in the Sony case only 9% of taping done by Sony Betamax video recorders at the time was considered ‘authorised/legal’ at the time. He also argued that there was a clear future market for non infringing uses of “Grokster-type peer-to-peer software”.
Breyer argues the real question this case throws up is whether as MGM would suggest the Sony doctrine is modified, or as recommended by Justice Ginsberg in his concurring opinion interpreted more strictly. He stated in his opinion “Fairly appraised, the evidence was insufficient to demonstrate, beyond genuine debate, a reasonable prospect that substantial or commercially significant noninfringing uses were likely to develop over time. On this record, the District Court should not have ruled dispositively on the contributory infringement charge by granting summary judgment to Grokster and StreamCast. If, on remand, the case is not resolved on summary judgment in favour of MGM based on Grokster and StreamCast actively inducing infringement, the Court of Appeals, I would emphasize, should reconsider, on a fuller record, its interpretation of Sony’s product distribution holding.
The later is not something Breyer agrees with. Such an approach, would he argues, require defendents “to produce considerably more concrete evidence.more than was presented here to earn Sony’s shelter. That heavier evidentiary demand, and especially the more dramatic (case-by-case balancing) modifications that MGM and the Government seek, would, I believe, undercut the protection that Sony now offers [and] increase the legal uncertainty that surrounds the creation or development of a new technology capable of being put to infringing uses”
The case has now been remanded to the lower court
First thoughts: Surprise at unanimous ruling – although Breyers concurring opinion was at least a more balanced view of the situation.
What is interesting, is that the main thrust of the case seems to be the “affirmative steps to foster infringement.” This would seem to protect iPOd users etc and indeed possibly other p2p operators. Does this mean if P2P operator X is out there and has never tried to market itself as somewhere to get illegal downloads but then if its software is used for them, it would be ok and protected by Sony???