Some od Europe’s top mobile telecoms companies received a blow yesterday when Advocate General Kokot of the European court of justice has issued an opinion that the cost of 3G licences does not include VAT. A group of Uk and Austrian mobile operators are arguing that the allocation of the 3G rights was a transaction subject to VAT under EU legislation and that the payments made for using the frequencies had therefore contained VAT, which the mobile operators say they should be able to claim back.
The reason for this is obviously that the operators paid hugely over the odds for the licences and are ow clutching at any straws to get some of that cash back.
Advocate General Kokot disagreed stating their was no duty to charge VAT in this case as the State and its institutions were carrying out an activity required of them as public authorities. The ECJ will deliver its own judgment in due course and is not bound by the Advocate General`s Opinion (although usually confirms the advocates opinion in around 80% of cases).