Information Overlord

Literature, Law, Librarianship and More

  • Adoption
  • Books
  • Law & Legal
  • Libraries & KM
  • Media & Broadcasting
  • Politics
  • Telecoms
You are here: Home / Uncategorized / Another US online child protection law ruled unconstitutional

Another US online child protection law ruled unconstitutional

14th September 2004 by Scott

The US District court for the Eastern district of Pennsylvania has ruled in favour of the Center for Democracy & Technology and the American Civil Liberties Union declaring the Pennsylvania Internet Child Pornography Act unconstitutional, and permanently enjoining the state from issuing any informal notices or court orders, or taking action against any ISP that failed to comply with any such notices or orders to block access to websites that were alledged to contain child porn.

On the face of it, this may seem like madness to someone just reading the headlines, but the rational behind the decision was clear and logical. The question was no about the rights and wrongs of whether sites containing child porn should be blocked – most would probably agree this is a good thing – but more whether the approach taken by this law was an exceptable way. The Court found that the use of DNS and IP address blocking methods both overblocked vast numbers of innocent sites -over 500,000 in some cases that were sharing either the DNS path or IP address. Also the ISPs were faced with the fact that they were having to implement blocking nationaly, to comply with a state law.

As we have seen previously with COPA passing a law with good intentions that is badly written and implemented will resltin the Courts taking action.

One of the most important issues raised by the plaintiffs in the US case of permenantley blocking sites, and there being no process in place to monitor if individual sites are now ‘clean’. This would also apply in the UK to BT’s ‘cleanfeed’ filtering technology.How would a purchaser of a doamian name know or find out if the domain that had just purchased is being ‘filtered’ or blocked by an ISP? In the US case the CDT demonstated at trial that they were able to purchase the domain http://www.littleangels.tv.tr , a site that had been permanentl blocked by several ISPs and produce a ligitimate website.

And all these laws leave open the bigger question of why more is not being done to actually go after and arrest those responsible for putting child porn on the web. These laws seek to hide it away, so we can pretend it’s not there, rather than actually do anything about the problem itself.

Filed Under: Uncategorized

Archives

Categories

Copyright © 2026 · Magazine Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in