The ASA has upheld complaints against Carphone Warehouse regarding a number of ads across a range of media for a new TalkTalk telephone package which offered “free” broadband and promised “free broadband forever”.
Whilst the ASA accepted that the advertiser had relied on the CAP (Broadcast) Help Note on “Free” claims, the ASA pointed out that this related to existing packages and that in these cases if an extra element is added they could be described as “free” for a reasonable period as long as the original package (without the extra element) had been available beforehand at the same price, again for a reasonable period. They considered that, because T3I was a brand new package, and the intention was that the broadband element would always be an optional extra to that package, the broadband was, to all intents and purposes, a constituent part of the new T3I package. Also, it was only available as an option to people who signed up to an 18-month contractual commitment; paid a connection charge of of £29.99 to sign up and who continued to pay a monthly charge of £9.99 per month plus line rental (£20.99 in total) and a disconnection fee of £70. According to the ASA this made broadband an intrinsic part of the new T3I calls package which made it different to “free insurance” or “buy one get one free offers”.
As the ASA did not consider the broadband could be described as free they considered the claim “free forever” to be misleading, and noted that even if the broadband could be described as “free” they did not consider it was possible for TalkTalk to substantiate the claim “free forever”. Inevitably, for those people who had signed up to the offer when it was advertised as “free”, the broadband would become “inclusive” after a reasonable period of time because they would continue to pay £20.99 a month. The benefit of “free” broadband would therefore stop once it became inclusive because customer’s future payments would be for an “inclusive” rather than “free” aspect of what they were paying for.
Finally the ASA found that the ads did not make it sufficiently clear that the availability of broadband was dependent on being connected to a qualifying telephone exchange and that people not connected to such an exchange would have to pay a further £10 per month for the broadband service.
The ASA told the advertiser not to repeat the claims in further advertising.
Carphone Warehouse has said it will continue to make the claims as it has since adjusted its offer to include “free broadband” with its Talk3 package – which existed before both T3I and the broadband offer