Information Overlord

Literature, Law, Librarianship and More

  • Adoption
  • Books
  • Law & Legal
  • Libraries & KM
  • Media & Broadcasting
  • Politics
  • Telecoms
You are here: Home / Uncategorized / Bad week for Uk Govt on ID Cards

Bad week for Uk Govt on ID Cards

16th January 2006 by Scott

The UK Government’s ID Card Scheme has had another tough week. First the London School of Economics (LSE) released their second report on the Scheme, which once again was critical of the handling of the scheme and the Government’s refusal to reveal the true cost of the scheme; Second the House of Lords inflicted three defeats on the bill including one that agreed that the House would block the progress of the bill until the National Audit Office (NAO) and MPs vet the figures put forward by the government on the cost of the scheme

“No provision of this Act, except sections 38, 39 and 45 . . . shall be brought into force until the Secretary of State has laid before Parliament a report in accordance with subsection (2), and that report has been approved by the House of Commons”
 
The  government, in the guise of Home Office Minister Andy Burnham, who once again has been given the job of defending the government position, and of repeating the same stock phrases and sentences that the Home Office has been issuing for two years said “People want us to keep the costs of the ID cards down but this amendment would limit the government’s ability to do that. It would require us to put into the public domain costs we want to keep back as we want to get the best possible deal for the taxpayers”. 

Here he was repeating statements that gave the reason for the government not releasing exact costs (or estimates). That the government is trying to use commercial secrecy to hide behind it’s duty to Parliament and the country is made all the more interesting when their argument that revealing costs would mean that “no one would dream of bidding lower than our forecast costs” , and would prevent the government from securing “value in a highly competitive environment”.
 
As Baroness Noakes commented if the Government are procuring in competitive markets, the bidding behaviour that the noble Baroness describes is simply not credible, and that the size of the contracts involved will make them very attractive to those in the industry who will be bidding to win the contract from their competitors not matching the government’s bottom line. Lord Crickhowell took up this line of argument when he pointed out that in a response to the fact that fact that Lord Chancellor had given the Lords an estimate of the cost of the setting up and building the Supreme Court, Baroness Scotland said: “The issues that arise from which building to buy for the Supreme Court are different from the issues we now have to deal with, for this reason: the provision of secure facilities and managed IT data centres is a highly competitive market”. As he riley commented, presumably Baroness Scotland was arguing at that the construction industry was not a highly competitive market.  

Some of the Lords asked just what the Government had to hide. They pointed out that they are so secretive abut their cost that they refused an offer of a secret session of the Lords [“Upon an Order for a secret sitting, the Chamber shall be cleared of all persons, except Lords of Parliament, the Clerks at the Table, Black Rod and the Serjeant-at-Arms, and thereupon the proceedings shall be secret. Members of the House of Commons shall not be required to withdraw under this Standing Order”]. This is a move hardly ever used, but the several Lords suggested it so that the costs could be discussed in detail without any commercial confidentiality complications. The Government declined. 

According to the LSE none of the vendors they spoke to believed that projected costs have any bearing on the bidding process. 

The LSE report stood by its cost estimates from its initial report in June 2005, but changed its overall position on the idea of an ID Card scheme saying that “In the light of the numerous inconsistencies and conflicts that have emerged, serious unanswered concerns that remain, project dynamics that are dysfunctional and potential outcomes that may be harmful to the public interest we can now no longer support even the principle of an identity scheme owned and operated by the Home Office. Its primary purposes remain unsubstantiated, its benefits remain unclear and its costs opaque”.

The Bill will now return to the Commons where the government is expected to reject the amendments.

The new Conservative leader David Cameron this week called ID Cards ‘un-British’ and vowed to oppose the ID card plans. “I don’t like ID cards, I don’t like the idea that you have to have this bit of paper just for existing,” he told BBC’s Sunday AM, saying there were practical reasons for opposing the scheme too.

Filed Under: Uncategorized

Archives

Categories

Copyright © 2026 · Magazine Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in