Bob Cargill, Senior creative director, Yellowfin Direct Marketing has posted an interesting response to an article written by Robert Bly in DM News called Can Blogging Help Market Your Product .Bly’s conclusion in that article was No. Total waste of time and money, and “pure vanity publication “.
To be fair Bly, a well known and regarded, marketing copywriter is, like us all only talking from personal experience, so when he says “The first is that most blogs I encounter are rambling, streams-of-consciousness musings about a topic of interest to the author, largely bereft of the practical, pithy tips that e-zines, Web sites and white papers offer” I’ll take him at his word, but have to think that he’s obviously not finding the right blogs.
He also says the problem with blogs is monitoring them: “With an e-zine, once the reader subscribes, he gets it delivered to him electronically every week or month or however often you send it. But with a blog, the reader has to go out and proactively look for it. And since your contributions to your blog may be irregular and unscheduled, he has no way of knowing when something new of interest has been added” Cargill points out what 99% of you reading this are shouting – ‘RSS’ !!
Finally Bly seems to think that Blogs are not interactive in any way … “Even bulletin boards are interactive, so they have value by virtue of shared opinions, dialogue and engaging conversation that may be listened to openly and publicly. But most blogs seem to be the private, idiosyncratic musings of an individual, without censure or editing of any kind. And the result is like porridge: a gloppy mess, tasteless and not very satisfying”
Ok, now I am wondering what blogs Bly has been looking at – Most blogs now have comment fields that give exactly the interactive nature he wants, or maybe he’d be better off with Wiki’s? Cargill himself points Bly to his own blog
In a recent post on Forrester’s Catherine Li, I quoted from an interview with her, where she said: “people who have never realized that Forrester had coverage in their fields are contacting me. It gives us more exposure. Obviously, I wouldn’t be doing this unless there was some sort of hope that it would help our clients, attract new clients and exert a greater influence in the marketplace”
And it seems were not the only one who disagree with Bly, the people at business blog consulting do too
I was not personally familiar with Bly before reading this article, but a friend who is has said that he writes very well on the subject of marketing. I can only say that I hope he researches his other writings better, as this particular piece displays little knowledge of the subject matter.
Bly is due to publish a response to the responses – Cargill’s in particular – in a column set to run 6th December. I will reserve final judgement until then.
Also worth looking at is a white paper (Bly trusts those) by Intelliseek on Consumer Generated Media (CGM). Whilst the company sell products to monitor online media, so have a vested interest they do identify some valid points about how the old marketing paradigm has changed with the invent of the internet and CGM, which they identify as consumer word of mouth behaviour (‘the most trusted and reliable form of advertising’) ,and including consumers sharing their opinions on Blogs, rating and review sites, forums, USENET Groups etc.
It goes onto say how monitoring these kind of forums allows marketers to: understand emerging trends/themes; benchmark against competitors; manage a brand/product etc; and react quickly to potential problems, all in ‘real time’.