A good week for the Government’s ID Card Bill. First a commons committee cast doubt on its compliance with Human Rights laws, and then ex Tory Cabinet Minister, Peter Lilley pens a scathing attack on the plan in report for the Tory think tank, the Bow Group.
I have to say he has really hit the nail on the head. This should be compulsory reading for all members of the UK population. Whilst I personally differ from his view that (outside of war
time) there is ever a good case to be made for compulsory ID Cards; I agree totally that the government has not offerered any evidence to back up any of the claims for the introduction of the cards – which this report demostrates quite clearly.
“Instead of wasting hundreds of millions of pounds on compulsory ID cards as the Tory Right demand, let that money provide thousands more police officers on the beat in our local communities.” (Tony Blair 1995).
Lilley’s arguments summarised:
- Compulsory ID cards would not address the real problem in tackling organised crime, terrorism and illegal immigration, which is not identifying suspects but proving them guilty or removing them. ID cards simply divert resources away from this area.
- Public support for ID cards rests on the mistaken belief that most immigration is illegal coupled with ignorance of the fact that all illegal immigrants can, and most do, claim asylum at which point they are already given an ID card. Most supporters of ID cards believe the police will check the ID of anyone who looks ‘foreign’. Yet that would be odious and unsustainable since it would force ethnic minority citizens constantly to justify their presence.
- The public sector’s record in the successful implementation of IT projects is woeful; and this would be the biggest yet.
- Biometric technology still involves high levels of error. At present success rates, even if each UK citizen only had their card checked once a year, 4 million people would be falsely accused of not being who they are.
- On the government’s own figures the cost is huge – £5.5 billion over ten years – so a passport/ID card will cost £85 per adult. All past experience and independent experts suggest the cost could easily double. This could be Labour’s poll tax.
- If the scheme does not require everyone to carry and produce cards at all times the claimed benefits would largely disappear.
- Yet if carrying cards is made compulsory even leaving leave home without one would be an offence; failure to notify a change of address means a £1,000 fine and failure to register means a £2,500 fine.
- The introduction of compulsory ID cards in peacetime has been the preserve of fascist and communist states; such plans have always been intended to control their citizens. Common law countries have all rejected them in peacetime.
- In sum, compulsory ID cards represent an unjustifiable encroachment on liberty in return for at best minor benefits, and at huge financial cost which would be better spent on more police or better control of our borders.
I was impressed enough to email Mr Lilley and congratulate him on this document. Hopefully MP’s from all sides will read this and put an end to this idea as soon as possible.
The bill gets its third reading in the House of Commons on Wednesday.