Whilst I was away I caught up on a few things including reading a report prepared by the Rhode Island section of the ACLU on how Rhode Island libraries are implementing their legal requirement to filter library internet access, after the Supreme Courts CIPA decision. Regular readers will know I have written on this subject before several times before most recently in an article for Electronic Business Law – Censoring Net content: the CIPA decision
The report makes interesting reading, especially for those that hope to see the law challenged. The Rhode Island libraries have implemented a state-wide solution using websense software to block sites. Most of the libraries have chosen to adopt three categories to block to comply with CIPA: Sex, Adult Content, and Nudity. The later of these is interesting as Websense describes this as sites that offer depictions of nude or semi-nude human forms, singly or in groups, not overtly sexual in intent or effect, which immediately puts it outside of what CIPA mandates that libraries must block visual depictions that are obscene; or child pornography, and appeals to a prurient interest in nudity, and lacks serious literary or artist merit.
The nudity category clearly falls outside of that. So already many of the libraries are already going beyond the law, and therefore open to charges of blocking access to protected free speech. Worryingly on top of this many of the libraries had also added categories to block, such as games sites, gambling sites, and all chat sites.
Others have adopted additional keyword blocks – again as the law is aimed at images this already causes problems – the report writers found one library blocked a google search for nudism, with the keyword on screen listed as udis (so it would also for example block any site using the word prudish.
Another worrying aspect of the report is the apparent lack of library policies on blocking and unblocking of sites, training of staff, and a general understanding of what the law says you can, and can not do – demonstrated by the lack of information informing patrons of their rights to have blocking software disabled or to have sites unblocked; staff refusing to provide unfiltered access, and misleading internet access policies that do not mention filters or CIPA
It seems logical to conclude the experience in Rhode Island is unlikely to be an isolated one, which on the one hand has to be a worrying trend, but on the other hand maybe this will make a challenge to the implementation of the Act more likely to happen sooner rather than later.
Meanwhile in the UK the LSE has just published the report of a two-year study into Internet use and abuse, based on face-to-face interviews with children called UK Children Go Online
The report is a good overview of children use of the internet, their encounters with pornography, their understanding on protecting their personal information online etc and computer literacy. The report makes several recommendations to policy makers, internet service providers, teachers, parents and children:
- Recognise the complexity of access when designing information and advice campaigns
- Direct children and young people towards valuable content
- Address the changing conditions of digital exclusion
- Improve levels of internet literacy
- Develop critical evaluation skills
- Develop online advice resources with the help of young people
- Facilitate the shift from just receiving to also creating content
- Rethink online participation from having your say to being listened to
- Continue efforts to prevent exposure to undesirable content
- Maintain internet safety awareness
- Encourage parental sharing in childrens internet use
- Respect childrens online privacy in the home
- Take care not to reduce young peoples online opportunities
- Target guidance and regulation more carefully at different groups of children
- Design websites which encourage internet literacy
- Develop more and better child and youth portals
Worth reading for anyone interested in this topic.