The UK House of Commons Science & Technology Committee have published their report into Open Access in the UK – “Scientific Publications: Free for all?”.The Committee recognise that there is a growing problem with academic libraries struggling to purchase subscriptions to all the journal titles needed by their users. This is due both to the high and increasing journal prices imposed by commercial publishers (“we are not entirely convinced by the cost-justification argument employed by publishers to explain rising prices”) and the inadequacy of library budgets to meet the demands placed upon them by a system supporting an ever increasing volume of research. This Report recommends that all UK higher education institutions establish institutional repositories on which their published output can be stored and from which it can be read, free of charge, online. It also recommends that Research Councils and other Government funders mandate their funded researchers to deposit a copy of all of their articles in this way.
Calls on Government to:
“provide adequate funds for the British Library to establish and maintain a central online repository for all UK research articles that are not housed in other institutional repositories”
“Government ascertain what impact a UK-based policy of author copyright retention would have on UK authors. Providing that it can be established that such a policy would not have a disproportionately negative impact, Research Councils and other Government funders should mandate their funded researchers to retain the copyright on their research articles, licensing it to publishers for the purposes of publication”
Advocates further examination of author-pays model. “We see institutional repositories as operating alongside the publishing industry. In the immediate term they will enable readers to gain free access to journal articles whilst the publishing industry experiments with new publishing models, such as the author-pays model.
Says subscribers should be guaranteed “continuing access in the event of cancellation to articles published during the subscription period is written into its next national licensing deal” Frankly this one should apply to anyone taking a sub to a journal via electronic access.
Interesting, it also has a vieled accusation of Elsevier’s opportunism in announcing their Open Access conversion: “Elsevier is no sudden convert to Open Access. The company has seen the direction of trends in publishing and has acted accordingly to minimise criticism of its current policies. We are in little doubt that Elsevier timed the announcement of its new policy on self-archiving to pre-empt the publication of this Report. It is good news that our inquiry has prompted such a high profile endorsement of increased access to research papers. Nonetheless, there are a number of serious constraints to self-archiving in the model proposed by Elsevier”