Information Overlord

Literature, Law, Librarianship and More

  • Adoption
  • Books
  • Law & Legal
  • Libraries & KM
  • Media & Broadcasting
  • Politics
  • Telecoms
You are here: Home / Uncategorized / COPA Case

COPA Case

26th October 2006 by Scott

The eight year battle over the constitutionality of the 1998 Child Online Protection Act (COPA) began again this week as the US Government went to Court seeking to overturn a ruling, upheld by the Supreme Court, that the Act may be unconstitutional because the US Government had failed to prove that there were not less restrictive means of protecting children from obscenity online.

The Supreme Court, in a seven-to-four ruling, remanded the case back to the District Court for trial. In doing so, it re-asserted the view that the decision to allow the preliminary injunction on COPA to stand meant that the Government must ‘shoulder its full constitutional burden of proof respecting the less restrictive alternative argument, rather than excuse it from doing so’ – the US Constitution demands that content-based restrictions on speech must be presumed invalid, unless the Government can show their constitutionality.

Regular readers will know I have written about COPA on a number of occasions. I have just read the transcripts of the first two days on the case and have a few comments on what has taken place thus far. First off, I can not help but be amused that in the case on the issue of the effectiveness of filters the ACLU and the US government have pretty much switched sides in where they were in the Children’s Internet Protection Act (CIPA) case where the government position was that to receive federal funding public libraries with computer terminal must install filters to block children accessing harmful material, and that filters worked, whereas the ACLU argued then that they didn’t really work because they both underblocked and overblocked material. Although to be fair to the ACLU, at that time they were more arguing that the government shouldn’t be mandating the use of filters.

In their opening statement the government lawyers set out their stall. The reason for COPA? ‘government action is necessary to address the pornography problem on the web’ [This will be why they interfered in the .xxx decision obviously] And, ‘It is intended to regulate the commercial pornography industry’ [Shame it doesn’t say that in the text then really, isn’t it] ‘The solution to the pornography problem. COPA’ . What’s more they dragged out the old argument of ‘ Copa is nothing more than the technological equivalent of the plastic wrapper on penthouse magazine in a book store’.

Filters don’t solve problems. The government say even the best filters allowed 8.6% of sexually explicit pages through, and that’s not good enough. ‘If a water source was mixed with a sewer system, and you had a filter that screened out all but 8.6% of it, would that be a solution to the problem? Would that cure the problem of the drinking water? I think that analogy works here with kids’.

Ah yes, this law which applies to US based content and would not apply to any porn / explicit sexual content hosted overseas (so would not apply to around 50% of all such material) is going to much more effective at preventing US children’s exposure to explicit material. I think not. No, wait, the government say. COPA applies worldwide ‘ Other internet laws have been applied outside of the United States, most famously the laws involving internet gambling. Courts have found no difficulty establishing jurisdiction over foreign based websites that seek business in the United States and process payments from US consumers’ This seems a red herring to me, as the internet gambling law is not so much banning internet gambling as banning the credit card companies from taking payments from such sites. Is the US about to introduce a similar law and apply it to overseas porn? I look forward to that one.

Parents are left with a difficult choice we are told, because without COPA they can either let their little darlings be exposed to endless porn or use filters that cuts off access to other stuff that would be fine for them, and materials which ‘in many cases are necessary for a child to complete his homework’. Let’s just hope he’s not down the library doing his homework where the very same government has the very same filters put in the protect those parents’ children against all that nasty porn.

The only problem I see for the ACLU in this case is that the Judge just wont believe that the publishers testifying are in any real danger of prosecution under COPA. I’ll admit I don’t. However as COPA is worded – as despite the government saying that they certainly would not be caught by COPA – the fact remains that they could be, and that is why in the end to court should re-affirm its original decision.

Trial transcripts: Day One / Day Two

Filed Under: Uncategorized

Archives

Categories

Copyright © 2026 · Magazine Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in