Information Overlord

Literature, Law, Librarianship and More

  • Adoption
  • Books
  • Law & Legal
  • Libraries & KM
  • Media & Broadcasting
  • Politics
  • Telecoms
You are here: Home / Uncategorized / Court Lets Child Porn man off

Court Lets Child Porn man off

5th October 2004 by Scott

The 11th Circuit Court of Appeal last week overturned the conviction of a Florida man for possessing child pornography because the law used to prosecute him, the US Federal interstate commerce clause, was not a valid law under which to make the prosecution.

James Maxwell had been convicted of 2 counts of knowingly possessing child pornography and sentence to 66 months in prison under the SD commerce clause which states “Any person who . . . knowingly possesses any book, magazine, periodical, film, videotape, computer disk, or any other material that contains an image of child pornography that has been mailed, or shipped or transported in interstate or foreign commerce by any means, including by computer, or that was produced using materials that have been mailed, or shipped or transported in interstate or foreign commerce by any means, including by computer . . . shall be punished as provided in subsection (b).”

According to the court the jurisdictional element of the offence, meant that the statute required the Government to prove that the child pornography, or at least the material that produced it, travelled in interstate commerce. At Maxwell’s trial the Jury was told that the disks containing the images were ‘manufactured outside the state of Florida and have been mailed, shipped or transported in interstate commerce. The Government did not establish that the child pornography moved across state lines. Consequently, its case relied on establishing that the images were ‘produced’ by materials that did.

In his appeal Maxwell argued that because the government had only demonstrated that he stored images as opposed to ‘producing’ them – as the disks could not ‘produce’ the images, his convictions must be overturned. The Court disagreed. However the court did find the use of the commerce clause to prosecute Maxwell was faulty as the Government had not shown that Maxwell’s case involved no activity beyond Florida and “the act of possession alone entails no transactions, no consumption of good and services, and no necessary resort to the marketplace” and therefore the court concluded Maxwell’s conduct did not “substantially affect” interstate commerce enough for Congress to regulate it under the U.S. Constitution.

According to the court “Federalism ensures a role for the governments of the states and affords the voting public a more resonant voice in the debate over many legislative issues of principally local concern. We decline today, with no small regret about the outcome in this case, to ignore that design, even in favour of strengthening the hand of federal law enforcement in the salutary aim of eradicating child pornography”.

From the outside the choice of the federal interstate commerce clause and not State pornography laws to prosecute Maxwell seems strange.

I have little doubt that due to the subject matter of the case it will not be surprising to see this case back before the courts again. If so, once again it will be a difficult one for the courts, as sadly, due to the wording of the law (as stands) it is easy to see how the Appeal court reached its decision.

Filed Under: Uncategorized

Archives

Categories

Copyright © 2026 · Magazine Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in