Today Advocate General Christine Stix-Hackl delivered Opinions concerning the interpretation of the database directive in than four cases that have been referred to the European Court of Justice (ECJ) for preliminary rulings.
These all deal with sporting ‘databases’. The first case British Horseracing Board Ltd and others v William Hill Organization Ltd (see Uk court ruling) deal with data used by william Hill for online betting derived from BHB’s database; Fixtures Marketing Ltd v Oy Veikkaus Ab; Fixtures Marketing Ltd v Organismos Prognostikon Agonon Podosfairou; and Fixtures Marketing Ltd v Svenska Spel AB deal with efforts made by Fixtures Marketing to establish its right to enforce database rights in English and Scottish football Premiership fixture lists against european businesses that extract data for betting purposes.
All of the cases centre around the so called ‘sui generis’ right under the EU database directive. The sui generis right that was designed to protect the contents of organised collections of data, even if the compilation of data fell far short of a work of authorship that was entitled to copyright protection.
The Advocate General made several recommendations regarding questions that the Court of Justice should answer.
Watching the final outcome of these cases will be interesting; especially with regards what constitutes a ‘new and separate database’ , as to ‘substantial change’ to the contents of a database which qualify for database protection in its own right (and its own 15yrs protection a database must do that) But how do you quantify ‘substantial change’? without removing sui generis protection or by granting what would be in effect perpetual copyright protection of material in a database that might be non copyright?