The EU Commissioner for Justice, Freedom and Security, Franco Frattini has told the EU Parliament that the Commission will introduce a new proposal on the retention of data by telecoms companies in spring 2005 and that a general proposal on data protection would follow in October or November. Frattii said that the Commission sees no legal basis for a framework decision with the EU Council on mandatory data retention, and that he would try to convince the Justice & Home Affairs Council to withdraw its proposal so the commission can put forward its alternative.
The current proposal, which was put forward jointly by France, Ireland, Sweden and the United Kingdom in April 2004, is designed to achieve the approximation of Member States’ legislation relating to the retention of communications data as a means of helping to combat crime. Communications data includes telephone and internet subscriber information, itemised call records and mobile phone location data. The proposal does not relate to the content of the data or to the interception of communications. The declared aim of the proposal is to reduce the differences between legislation in the Member States, which are said to be prejudicial to co-operation between law enforcement agencies.
The Uk’s House of Lord’s EU Committee issued a report this week, After Madrid: The EU’s Response to Terrorism, which reviewed the draft framework and “found it seriously defective in several respects.”
- despite its controversial nature, it was not accompanied by a detailed explanatory statement (as it would have been if it had been a Commission proposal);
- its ambit is unjustifiably broad, since under it data would be retained for the purpose of combating crime, without further qualification, rather than serious crime as recommended by the Committee of Privy Counsellors chaired by Lord Newton that reviewed the Anti-terrorism, Crime and Security Act 2001;
- the degree of approximation involved seems half-hearted at best: Member States would be required to retain data for between 12 months and three years, but could derogate from this requirement in relation to certain categories of data and could also have a longer retention period;
- the Information Commissioner did not appear to have been consulted; and
- no Regulatory Impact Assessment was submitted, despite the acknowledged effect on service providers.
We accept, they go on to say, that, subject to appropriate safeguards, the retention of communications data may be justified as a weapon in the fight against terrorism and other serious crime but we believe that its application to all crime would be disproportionate. It may be difficult to draw a satisfactory line between serious and less serious crime, and a regular pattern of smaller crimes may sometimes amount to serious crime, but we would not regard it as acceptable for the police to have unlimited access to this data.
The Committee report that they have sent a letter to the Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State at the Home Office, who has undertaken to provide a regulatory impact assessment.
On the face of it, it is good news that the Commission is looking to start again from scratch on this topic, as the current proposal would actually achieve very little of the harmonisation it claims, nor has anyone put forward compelling reasons as to why retention over preservation is more successful, cost effective, and less needlessly intrusive.