Last week, the European Parliament once again voted against the European Commission’s ‘agreement’ to allow the transfer of EU airline passenger data to US authorities. The Commission and Council decided to call for another vote by calling for yet another vote – this time on the international agreement authorising the transfer of personal data. They seemed to be hoping that the MEP’s from the new member states would help reverse Parliament’s view. Instead to vote against the EU-US PNR deal increased from 16 to 42. The Commission and Council can, and will, go ahead and adopt the international agreement authorising the passing of data to the US, whilst the Parliament’s court case goes to the European Court of Justice (ECJ) to rule on. The Commission and Council will be hoping that by the time the ECJ rules on the case, the objections will be moot.
Whether this cause is the right one to fight on over the privacy of EU citizens is open to question, the world will not fall apart by the agreement being entered into. However, whether you agree with them or not, we do have EU data protection laws in the guise of the data protection directive, and under that directive it is clear that these transfers are certainly in breach of EU law. The ELECTED side of the EU seems to recognise this – in deed they have done so now three times. The UNELECTED side has chosen to ignore them – as is within their right under the EU treaty. What better way to demonstrate democracy than for the unelected to over-rule the elected, and force them to take court action. The Commission and Council should delay signing any agreement before the court rules, which the court should do as a fast track matter of urgency.
Read more on this topic at the excellent statewatch site