Judge A. Howard Matz of the U.S. District Court of the Central District of California said in an order granting a preliminary injunction published Tuesday that pornographic magazine and website producer Perfect 10 is likely to succeed in proving that Google (and Amazon’s A9 image search) directly infringe its copyright by creating and displaying thumbnail copies of its photographs in its search results. “Google’s creation of thumbnails of P10’s copyrighted full size images, and the subsequent display of those thumbnails as Google image search results, likely do not fall within the fair use exception”
However, he also added that Perfect 10 was unlikely to succeed in proving that Google can be held liable for aiding copyright infringement by pointing internet searchers to infringing sites, or that Google’s Adsense program will be found to materially contribute to direct infringement by third party websites.
According to Matz “The principal two-part issue in this case arises out of the increasingly recurring conflict between intellectual property rights on the one hand and the dazzling capacity of Internet technology to assemble, organize, store, access and display intellectual property ‘content’ on the other.”
The owner of the Perfect 10 website, Norm Zada, launched his lawsuit against Google in 2004, claiming that he feared his company, which claims 100,000 unique visitors a month to its Web site, would be driven out of business unless Google is forced to stop distributing the “free peeks” of its copyrighted content.
Perfect 10 accuse Google of copying, reproducing, distributing, adapting and publicly displaying their images in its image search engine results; linking to third party websites that are displaying stolen content from Perfect 10 – images they would not be able to locate without the help of Google; failing to block access to sites hosting this stolen content; profiting (through their Adsense program) from sites hosting this content; and linking to password hacking sites that provide ways to gain illegal access to Perfect 10’s Web site.
The court looked carefully at what constitutes a “display” of an image. The Court found there was no dispute that Google “in-line links” to and/or “frames” content that is stored on other websites. The question was did this constitute a “display”. The court weighed up arguments in favour of the ‘server’ test and the ‘incorporation’ test to decide this point. The ‘Server’ test argues that if site A has used standard html to in-line link (and show) an image on site A that is hosted on site B that the site where the image is hosted is the site that is “displaying” the image. Perfect 10 argued that as site A has incorporated site B’s image into its own site , that it is site A that is “displaying” the image, and this ‘incorporation’ test should guide the court. The Court found that adopting the incorporation test would cause ‘a tremendous chilling effect on the core functionality of the web – its capacity to link” as any site that in-line linked to or framed third party content would risk liability for direct infringement.
In this case the court accepted that Google does not store or serve any full-size images of Perfect 10 content on the Google Image Search, and that the use by Google of in-line linking and frames do not constitute a “display” of Perfect 10’s full-size images; therefore Perfect 10’s claims of infringement in relation to full-size images was likely to fail.
When the Court turned to the issue of whether or not the thumbnails infringed, the conclusion was very different. Key to this was the issue of licensing content for display on mobile phones.
In examining the questions of fair-use, the Court concluded that whilst it was “reluctant to issue a ruling that might impede the advancement of internet technology”, it was likely that Google’s creation and display of thumbnails of Perfect 10’s content does not fall within the fair-use exception. Google’s thumbnails do lead users to sites that – if include those involved in their adsense program – this does directly benefit Google’s profits. However, the Court stressed that a commercial use did not preclude a finding of fair use if the use is transformative rather than consumptive. The Court found that Google’s use of thumbnails was transformative – as it enhances search functionality, however it also found them to be consumptive in this case, primarily due to a third party licensing deal Perfect 10 has with Fonestarz to deliver smaller (thumbnail size) versions of their content to UK mobile phone subscribers. According to the Court in this instance there was little if any difference between the content a user could download from Fonestarz at a cost and the thumbnail images of this content stored on Google’s servers that could be downloaded for free. So whilst Google’s use of thumbnails is not likely to affect the market for full-size images, it does harm the potential market for downloading Perfect 10’s reduced size content via mobile phones.
The Court rejected Perfect 10’s claims for contributory and vicarious infringement with the Court stating that Perfect 10 “overstates Google’s actual conduct and confuses search technology with active encouragement and promotion of infringing activity”, and had failed to establish that it is likely that Google’s Adsense program will be found to materially contribute to direct infringement by third party websites, or that Google has the ability to control the infringing activity of others on the web.
The Court asked the parties to propose jointly the language of an injunction that would balance the competing interests of protecting copyright and facilitating search, and to submit this to the court by 8 March 2006.
The market for premium mobile content is the surprise in this case for me, and the one which could cost Google the most. There is clear evidence that if the Court accepts that there is no discernable difference between the mobile versions of content supplied by Perfect 10 and Google’s cache of the thumbnail image then it makes sense that a user would be less likely to buy content that they could get for free via Google. The Court correctly dismissed as weak an argument from Google that as “P10 admits [that] this market is growing,” its “delivery of thumbnail search results” must not be having a negative impact pointing out that it may have grown even faster had the content not be available free via Google
The final outcome of this case – probably years away, as well as those brought by news organisations against Google, and the progress or not of the Google Print project will all be key in deciding just how we access information on the web in the future.
Other Views on the case: