The UK government’s ID Card Scheme came in for yet more criticism this week, when the House of Commons Science and Technology Committee inquiry into the technologies, scientic advice, risk and evidence criticised the governmentfor deciding what it wanted to do before it had determined if it would work.
The Committee were particularly disappointed that two years after a previous committee inquiry, by the Home Affairs Committee, criticised the Home Office for a lack of clarity about the ID Card plans, that the Home Office had still not given sufficient information about much of the proposed scheme – such as how and when the cards would work, what personal data will need to be revealed in different circumstances, and in setting a clear timetable for the publication of the technical specifications and the procurement process and planned stages.
Jerry Fishenden, national technology officer at Microsoft, told the committee ‘ I think there were only three scenarios on the website yesterday …there is one talking about somebody who is 18 going into an off-licence and being able to assert proof of their age, and a 70 year old looking for a 65 year old discount. It then goes on they reveal their date of birth in order to prove their age. To me that just highlights the type of issue we have been trying to flag up to the Home Office: Why would you want to reveal someone’s date of birth in that Scenario? You would want to reveal their age; their entitlement that is, that they are over 65. You do not even have to reveal their age, but that they are over 65. If you start revealing things like date of birth, then I think the banks and everyone else are going to have huge headaches. Because, what do you then ask when you phone up to access your online account? It is personal information … but that scenario has just said you are going to start handling that type of information out every time you use the ID card … I am concerned about aspects of that scenario and the fact that it could lead to greater ID fraud risk”
The Report also criticised the manner in which the government has handle public debate on the scheme. It suggested that the government would have been better to have produced a ‘dispassionate critique’ of the report from the LSE which claimed the government were under-estimating the potential costs of the scheme, rather than seeking to ‘undermine its credibility and motivation’ .
The Committee also questioned the Home Office’s apparent decision regarding what biometrics to use in the scheme before the process of gathering evidence of the reliability and appropriateness of particular biometric has been completed. The Committee states it is concerned by this apparent approach given that the Identity Cards Act does not specify the biometrics to be used, The Committee calls on the Home Office to remain flexible about biometrics and to act on evidence rather than preference.
Additionally the report recommends that the Home Office undertakes a cross-Government consultation regarding its plans for technology to support the identity card scheme before the specifications of the scheme are finalised and that it makes the findings of this consultation public.
Meanwhile the Information Commissioner, Richard Thomas, has ordered the government to release gateway reviews on the ID Card scheme. Thomas said that whilst the exemption relating to the formation of government policy had been applied correctly, that public interest outweighed the argument for keeping the documents secret, and that the Treasury and the Office of Government Commerce should therefore release their Gateway Reviews of the identity cards programme and the programme’s traffic light status.
In June the Commissioner ordered the Department for Works and Pensions to release research on the likely effect of the introduction of identity cards on DWP business.
It is believed that the DWP has appealed this decision, and it seems likely that the Treasury and the Office of Government Commerce will do the same, if for no other reason than to delay release of the information.
I’m sure the government would be also pleased to hear that Lukas Grunwald, a security consultant with DN-Systems in Germany has shown this week that he can clone the electronic passports that the United States and European countries are planning to begin to distribute this year. According to Grunwald as the RFID chips in the passport are not encrypted the data in the chips is easy to copy and replicate.