The Commons tossed back the Lords amendment and the Lords have thrown it back again, trying to force the Government into using the Parliament Act. The previous uses have all been on free votes or in the case of the Hunting Bill an agreement between the Parties.
Is the Lords right to stick it out? I think yes, and regardless of your opinion of whether ID Cards are a good or bad idea, if you value responsible government.
I quote from the latest Lords debate:
Lord Phillips of Sudbury:
By far the major part of the Home Secretary’s opening and closing speeches were devoted to trying to re-interpret the Labour Party manifesto at the election last year. At col. 1249 he quoted from the manifesto-and these words have been repeated several times:
“‘We will introduce ID cards, including biometric data like fingerprints, backed up by a national register and rolling out initially on a voluntary basis as people renew their passports'”.
Having repeated that, Mr Clarke continued:
“Passports are voluntary documents-[Laughter.]”-
that was not me, but Hansard-
“Well, of course they are.”,
said Mr Clarke.
“No one is forced to renew a passport if they choose not to do so”.-[Official Report, Commons, 13/3/06; col. 1249.]
I am afraid that my primary school teacher, Miss Lovelace, would have give Mr Clarke 0 out of 10 for that. She would have pointed out in the sweetest way, because she was never nasty to a wayward child, that the word “voluntary” in that sentence related to ID cards, not passports. It plainly did not say or mean to say, “We will introduce ID cards initially on a compulsory basis as people renew their passports voluntarily”. Indeed, more than 80 per cent of the population have passports. Yet that is the cock-eyed interpretation that is now pressed on the public by a government who seem to be losing their sense of shame.
In the same speech, he stated:
“That position is that the scheme will initially be based on a stand-alone identity card, issued on its own on a voluntary basis, or together with a document such as a passport, which is also issued on a voluntary basis. That seems to be clear and unequivocal”.-[Official Report, Commons, 13/3/06; col. 1249.]
Conceivably, Mr Clarke, that is so, but only so long as you do not link the two, as the designation process under Clauses 4 and 5 does, and only so long as the designation process does not, in making that link, force the citizen seeking or renewing a passport to take out an ID card as well. But that is precisely what it does. It staggers me that we are still discussing that point. Try that argument out on anyone in the high street or in a pub and you will get an “are you mad?” look.
Needless to say, out came Andy Burnham, a Home Office Minister, and said: “This has now been backed by the House of Commons three times. The time has come for the Lords to give way so we can get on with the job.” Or perhaps for the Labour party to take English Lessons, and learn the meaning of voluntary.