Information Overlord

Literature, Law, Librarianship and More

  • Adoption
  • Books
  • Law & Legal
  • Libraries & KM
  • Media & Broadcasting
  • Politics
  • Telecoms
You are here: Home / Uncategorized / Information Tribunal overturns ICO and orders BBC to release meeting minutes

Information Tribunal overturns ICO and orders BBC to release meeting minutes

10th January 2007 by Scott

The Freedom of Information Tribunal handed down an interesting decision on Monday requiring the BBC to release the minutes of its Governors meeting of 28 January 2004, in the wake of the Hutton Report, where the decision was made to part company with then, DG, Greg Dyke. The Information had been requested by both Heather Brooke, a freelance writer and Matt Wells of the Guardian newspaper.

The decision is interesting as much for the Tribunal view of how the Information Commissioner handled the case, as in the final decision to make the BBC release the information.

The ruling reversed decision notices issued by the Information Commissioner in February 2006 which had agreed that the section 36 exception applied and that “the public interest in maintaining this exemption currently overrides the public interest in disclosing the requested information”.

In particular the BBC relied upon s 36 (2) ii

s36 (2) Information to which this section applies is exempt information if, in the reasonable opinion of a qualified person, disclosure of the information under this Act-
(b) would, or would be likely to, inhibit-
(ii) the free and frank exchange of views for the purposes of deliberation,

The Tribunal looked at whether the opinion of the BBC was reasonable; and if it was, did the public interest in maintaining this exemption override the public interest in disclosing the requested information.

The s36 exemption is qualified because the material part of s 2(2) provides: In respect of any information which is exempt information by virtue of any
provision of Part II, section 1(1)(b) [ie, the right to have the information communicated] does not apply if or to the extent that-
…
(b) in all the circumstances of the case, the public interest in maintaining the exemption outweighs the public interest in disclosing the information.

Reasonableness

In assessing whether the first condition is met the Tribunal makes it clear that it is the qualified person’s opinion of the likelihood of inhibition and not the Commissioner’s nor the Tribunal’s, and if the opinion is reasonable under s 36, neither the Commissioner should or the Tribunal should substitute his own view for that of the qualified person. However, the Tribunal found little agreement on the sense in which the qualified person’s opinion is required by s 36(ii)(b) to be reasonable. It felt that to satisfy the statutory wording of s 36(2) the substance of the opinion must be objectively reasonable and reasonably arrived at.

When looking at the Commissioner’s decision notices, the Tribunal did not consider it self evident that the Commissioner had applied the right test in judging the reasonableness of the BBC opinion, and that in his statement of reasons he stated a position that was reflected in Commissioner’s Awareness Guidance No 25 which states:

“The Information Commissioner considers a reasonable opinion to be one which lies within the bounds of reasonableness or range of reasonable opinions and can be verified by evidence. Any opinion which is not outrageous, or manifestly absurd or made with no evidence, or made on the basis of irrelevant factors or without consideration of all relevant factors, will satisfy such a test. The Commissioner may well take a different view of what would have been the best decision in the circumstances, but this is immaterial where the qualified person’s opinion lies within the bounds of reasonableness”.

The Tribunal stated that it could not endorse the second sentence and that it should be disregarded as an opinion may be objectively unreasonable without being subject the any of the particular defects in that sentence.

However, the Tribunal – with reservations in relation to how they reached their decision – found that the BBC’s opinion on the likelihood of future inhibition was a reasonable opinion and therefore the minutes did constitute exempt information.

Public Interest

When it turned to the issue of public interest, the tribunal started by pointing to the assumption built into the FOIA that the disclosure of information by public authorities on request is in itself of value to the public interest. It then attacked the approach taken by the Commissioner again, stating that, contrary to the requirements of the FOIA his starting point had been one of non-disclosure based on the exemption when he said in order for the information to be released the arguments in favour of disclosing the information must outweigh those in favour of withholding it.

The tribunal contend that the reversal of the test coloured the Commissioner’s approach and hence affected his judgment of the balance of public interest.

The Tribunal said whilst they gave weight to the BBC’s opinion that disclosure would inhibit the free and frank exchange of ideas, it had to balance that with a view of the severity, and frequency with which this was likely to occur, and found the BBC evidence to support their view unimpressive.

The Tribunal pointed to the fact that the BBC took legal advice before approving the final minutes of the meeting in question. Whilst the BBC chose not to wave legal privilege to reveal what that advice said, the Tribunal stated that any competent advice would have advised the BBC that there was a chance that the minutes would not be protected under the s36 exemption due to the public interest test, and therefore the minutes would have been written up with that possible disclosure in mind.

This combined with other evidence left the Tribunal with the impression that “the BBC had a greater concern with the maintenance of secrecy than with the specifics of why these particularly important minutes should or should not be published”

The BBC now has 28 days to hand over the documents or appeal the ruling at the high court.

FOIA

In addition to looking at the cases, the tribunal also debated just what its jurisdiction was over proceedings and the meaning of one section of the FOIA .

For instance, it pointed to what Andrew Bartlett QC called the ‘curious wording’ of section 58(1) with regards to appeals by the tribunal and possible outcomes and in particular the use of the word or in “the Tribunal shall allow the appeal or substitute such other notice as could have been served by the Commissioner; and in any other case the Tribunal shall dismiss the appeal”

The Tribunal presumes that this is a drafting error and that the likely source of this sentence was section 48-49 of the Data Protection Act 1998, where appeals are only brought against notices by the data controller not data subjects. In the case of FOI, allowing appeals “entails stating what information must be released, which is the same a substituting such notice as could have been served by the Commissioner” and therefore the tribunal construed the subsections as if read with and ‘and/or’

Independence of Information Commissioner

The tribunal also questioned the appearance of independence and impartiality of the Commissioner that arose in the wording of the Memorandum of Understanding between the Secretary of State for Constitutional Affairs (on behalf of Government Departments) and the Commissioner on cooperation in relation to FOIA ss 50-51. “We were surprised to note from this document that it is the Commissione
r’s practice in some cases to issue to the public authority for comment a preliminary, non-statutory decision notice without also copying it to the applicant for comment. That seems to us to be a practice likely to give rise in the minds of applicants to concerns about the independence and impartiality of the Commissioner”.

Filed Under: Uncategorized

Archives

Categories

Copyright © 2026 · Magazine Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in