The importance of the use of language in drafting laws was highlighted last week when charges against a man who regularly visited child porn sites for the purpose of looking at child porn pictures was quashed when a Pennsylvania court ruled that the accused, Anthony Diororo did not ‘knowingly possess’ child pornography.
The Case revolved around the interpretation of section 6312 the Pennsylvania penal code which states:
Any person who knowingly possesses or controls any book, magazine, pamphlet, slide, photograph, film, videotape, computer depiction or other material depicting a child under the age of 18 years engaging in a prohibited sexual act or in the simulation of such acts commits an offence
The Court found that it was clear that the law criminalised the possession of child pornography but only did so if it was knowingly done, and did not in any way make it a crime to simply view child pornography absent of knowing possession.
The State had argued, and a lower court had agreed, that the presence of copies of images in Diororo’s internet cache demonstrated possession. The Superior Court however found that the the prosecution had provided no evidence that Diororo ever actively downloaded or saved any images, or that he was aware that the images were being automatically saved to his internet cache.
They concluded that “absent specific statutory language prohibiting the mere viewing of pornographic images or evidence that the defendant knowingly downloaded or saved pornographic images to his hard drive or knew that the web browser cached the images, he cannot be not criminally liable for viewing images on his computer screen. Therefore, we conclude that the evidence was insufficient to sustain Diodoro’s conviction for knowing possession of child pornography under section 6312(d)”.
Result: Diororo (who had originally been sentenced to 9-23 months) was discharged.