The always readable Julie Hilden has a good piece on Findlaw advocating the abandonment of the first sale doctrine. A brave stance to take if you’re not a record company or other media company with a vested interest. However, Hilden has produced a solid argument for believing that first sale must die if consumers and producers are to receive benefits from the digital age.
” Models that impose per-use charges could make pricing more efficient. In addition, they have the advantage of obvious fairness to the creator – who is paid based on how many people are entertained, and how often. This fairness, importantly, can be used to promote such models to the public. “
This should be accompanied by a much fairer pricing system to start off with. Hilden certainly hits the nail on the head when she says “In terms of business strategy, I believe that Napster taught (or should have taught) companies one huge lesson: People get extremely aggravated by artificial restrictions on distribution, and by prices failing to drop when distribution becomes effectively free because it can occur online, not through brick-and-mortar stores”.
She also advocates limited simultaneous DVD/Theatre release for films and a move to more paperback originals in books (no hard back first, then paperback later)
I’m not sure I am personally ready to ditch the first sale doctrine just yet, but Hilden is asking the questions that need to be asked and proving some possible answers.