I have now had time to read the report and the oral evidence taken as part of the report, and there are some interesting points made, none more so than those of Suw Charman of ORG who said “DRM is incapable of distinguishing between lawful and unlawful use”, and Toby Bainton of SCONUL who said “I think it is true that the statute has become less important and the contract more important”.
This certainly seem true in the UK where, it is the ‘market’ which is in control, sometime to an extent where DRM is actually preventing users/consumers being able to exercise rights that are legally available to them under UK laws. Although several of the lawyers who gave evidence were quick to point out of course, that, a practice and right most people think they have – to make a back up copy of their CDs for personal use, is not actually a permitted exception under UK copyright law.
Libraries made the interesting point that whilst section 28 of the Special Education Needs and Disabilities Act 2001 require institutions to ‘take reasonable steps’ to permit disabled people to enjoy facilities on the same basis as their peers that section 296 of the Copyright Designs and Patents Act 1998 does not allow interference/circumvention of DRM , even if it is to facilitate requirements of the SEND Act.
Labels
Taking one of the reports main points/recommendations – that of mandated labelling – in more detail, it was interesting to see APIG say that all CDs in future should come with a prominent label saying ‘you are not permitted to make any copies of this CD for any reason’
They go on … “ is likely that a full-disclosure label will also need to say “this CD may not play in all devices”. It will often have to go on to say, “if your current player device breaks or is stolen this content may become inaccessible” and “moving this content to a new device will not be possible if we cease supporting this platform or go out of business”.
For some types of content the labelling will need to warn the user, “you cannot access some parts of this DVD without a working Internet connection to enable us to record your identity”, or “your playing of this song may be recorded in marketing databases in foreign countries”.
Can you imagine how big this label will need to be? Of course I am sure content providers will just turn this into a long T&C document that people will never read – or online, click on (other than to accept).
That said, I feel this is a good idea.
Competition
The report addresses the need on some levels to keep an eye on competition and in particular asks if the dti should be looking at why the prices of music downloads in the UK are the same as those in the rest of the EU, finding it somewhat at odds with the idea of the EU ‘single market’
Again this is hard to argue with. The ‘cost’ of the digital product is the same to create.
Let the market decide
This seemed to be a popular argument in the non-DRM v DRM camps. Give consumers a choice of both and let them decide. I could not agree more. However, at the moment the decision is not do I pay itunes or Napster 79p for their DRM track , or do I pay EMusic the same for DRM free MP3’s? Well, if the major studio’s licensed their catalogues to services such as EMusic maybe we’d find out, but as they want to ‘protect’ their product against those naughty ‘pirates’ – no quite grasping that those naughty pirates are not going away, and a certain percentage of them are only downloading from p2p sites because they are not being offered what they want – DRM free music for their own personal use ‘legally’ anywhere
This is why Russian site AllofMP3 is now second only to iTunes in the UK. It’s ridiculously cheap, but if offers choice of download type and quality, and shows people will pay for ‘legal’ ( still open to discussion) downloads free of DRM. The first major EU or US site to copy this model – if it can get the majors to provide content will blow iTunes and all other competition out of the water.