Friend of the Blog People, ALA president elect Michael Gorman has been at it again. In an interview in CILIP’s Update magazine. At what again? Well, the funny thing with MG is that he manages to be wonderfully outspoken and mix sense with nonsense in equal measure (as many of us do)
He is a champion of what libraries have always stood for and their key importance in society. On the issue of the importance of libraries vital role in education he warns that those who believe in putting internet access in children’s libraries to keep them in touch with the information age are in danger of doing more harm than good.
‘Children can only benefit from electronic technology when they are firmly established as readers,’ he states, adding that literacy is ‘the major enabling technology in the development of reason, logic, systematic thinking and research,’ while the inadequate skills of many students accepted into higher education today ‘are the product of a society and a school system that has de-emphasised basic skills, including the most basic skills of all, in reading and writing’
I find myself agreeing with MG here, although I would add the proviso, that the presence of the internet in itself does not make people illiterate, teaching skill have perhaps just not adapted well enough to balance its presence.
Again, it’s hard not to argue with what he thinks libraries need to do: house print and tangible collections; provide spaces in which people can study, do research, read, view and listen for pleasure; provide places in which access to, and help in the use of, e-resources is available; provide meeting places within the community and provide suitable spaces for instruction.
But, I am less onside when MG claims that reading becomes less important because of technology is one of the ‘common delusions’ of technophiles. It’s certainly a delusion as I don’t know anyone that would argue anything so stupid, so I am interested in who is referring to there.
The best bits – saved to last: ‘The thing to do with a scholarly book is read it, preferably not on a computer screen.’ Metadata, he says is ‘a vastly inferior form of cataloguing, dreamed up by technophiles and other ignoramuses’. E-resources ‘have two problems: the majority of electronic documents in collections of data have no value at all and they are inherently unstable and shape-shifting’. So the question is not how to catalogue them – but what to catalogue.
‘Ignoramuses’ ??? – can we take any more of these ‘constructive’ comments?
Hard not to love him isn’t it. Best of all, he’s one of us too – a Brit.