On Monday to Government rejected – once again – an amendment from the House of Lords that would make the ID Card voluntary – as the Government claims it to be. The Lords tried to ensure that if you get or renew your passport, that the choice as to whether you also get an ID Card at that point be yours, and not the government’s. Sadly, the Government’s definition of voluntary is not one I am familiar with. According to Charles Clarke : “What we are saying is very clear and in accordance with the Labour party’s election manifesto, which stated:
We will introduce ID cards, including biometric data like fingerprints, backed up by a national register and rolling out initially on a voluntary basis as people renew their passports.
Passports are voluntary documents. Well, of course they are. No one is forced to renew a passport if they choose not to do so. That will remain the case once we begin issuing identity cards alongside passports”.
So there you have it. The ID card scheme IS voluntary because you do not have to renew your passport. So Labour’s interpretation of their manifesto pledge is one where voluntary means that if you want to continue to travel abroad – or at least outside the EU – you HAVE to have an ID Card or at least provide all the information needed for the ID Register.
It is funny the OED has this strange concept of voluntary being ” performed or done of one’s own free will, impulse, or choice; not constrained, prompted, or suggested by another”.
According to Mr Clarke it does not make sense to issue a biometric passport without an ID card. Funny, other countries (such as the US, seem to mange to do it ok). Also if that is the case why doesn’t the Bill say the scheme is compulsory from day one?
John Gummer said ” The Home secretary now suggests that, somehow or other, getting a passport is a voluntary concept. A passport is a right. It is what the government give us to say who we are when we wish to pass ports and go to other countries. We have a right to have it and no Home Secretary should deny it to us unless there is a genuine reason of state for his doing that. To tell us that we cannot have a passport unless we are prepared to pay extra for something that we do not want is not to suggest we have a voluntary choice”.
Edward Garnier added ” The Government have said that Identity Cards will defeat terrorism, welfare fraud, general crime, immigration breaches and identity fraud. They have said that it is vital to introduce identity cards and the national identity register to deal with those problems. If it were the magic of this scheme, they would not ‘let it roll out’ over the next 10 years; they would have introduced it yesterday or the day before.”
So it all goes back to the Lords again. Will the Lord back down this time or will they force the Government to use the Parliament Act again? Let us hope they stick to their guns. Labour like the Parliament Acts (1911 and 1949). They have only been used 7 times to force through legislation against the wishes of the Lords – one instance ironically being the 1949 Act. Three of these occasions have been with the current Government:
1999: European parliamentary Elections Act
2000: Sexual Offences Amendment Act
2004: Hunting Bill