Information Overlord

Literature, Law, Librarianship and More

  • Adoption
  • Books
  • Law & Legal
  • Libraries & KM
  • Media & Broadcasting
  • Politics
  • Telecoms
You are here: Home / Uncategorized / Not too Keen

Not too Keen

17th July 2007 by Scott

It has been pointed out to me by a few people in the past couple of weeks that my promised post on the Andrew Keen book – ‘The Cult of the Amateur’ as well as associated give away of said book has been slow in coming. I confess I have been lax; but not because I hadn’t finished the book – I did and I used up a lot of post-it notes doing so – but that the more I thought about it the more I thought that there was little point in giving the book any more oxygen. There was also the problem that when I fist thought of how I would cover it, I realised that I was picking up on so many points/claims etc that I would need to write a book in reply, which I really don’t have time to do, and is frankly more than the book actually deserves.

I should say, that this is not to say that there are not questions to be asked and debates to be had on issues surrounding web2.0, it is more that fact that Keen’s attempts to do so are rather amateurish.

It is also hard to ascertain just how much of what Keen writes he actually believes. He has admitted that the book is not a balanced view – it wouldn’t sell – and in the book’s final chapter he seems to tone down, if not recant, a lot of what has gone before. He claims not to be a Luddite but you’d be forgiven for not buying that after reading most of what is in his book. ” Digital technology is a miraculous thing” Keen tells us, but only if it is used to “protect the legacy of our mainstream media” – a mainstream media that Keen seems to have an idealised view of, one might add.

This is a mainstream media of truth and fact checking – remember that one, unlike Wikipedia. Ah yes, it’s is such an easy target and yes a lot of its several million entries and not great, but a lot are. How do you know which is which? Education and treating it as you would any other source, be it, the New York Times or Britannica (and let’s not forget one of those horrible ‘amateurs’ that Keen hates so much – a 12 year old Boy no less – had to contact them when the last version was published to point out “several errors and misleading statements” (in the words of Britannica themselves) that their ‘experts’ had written.

The picture you get reading this book is of a a man who wont buy anything, see anything, read anything unless an ‘expert’ tells him he should. Going to buy something and a neighbour has it already and says he has had lots of problems with it? Internet full of sites saying the same thing, but the expert reviewer in expert magazine says it’s good, Keen will take the experts view.

I could go on – believe me, I could go on – but for me, the book and Keen’s logic is summed up perfectly when at one point he seriously compares a decision by the band – the Barenaked Ladies – to allow fans to enter a contest to “remix” their songs – the best of which would appear on a CD as being the same as a “surgeon who, instead of performing the surgery, leaves the amateur in the operating chamber with some surgical instruments and a brief pep talk”.

I should say having written about COPA (Child Online Protection Act) on these pages a number of Times, also Keen ‘urged’ enforcement of it.

Anyway, as it would really pain me for Keen to profit any further than the £11.24 I have spent on this book, what I propose to do is offer it for free to anyone who emails me. There is a catch. The person I send it to must in turn promise to send it to another person for free once they have read it. One further catch is a slight delay whilst my friend Pete reads it – he’ll be quick.

And I’ll leave you with the OED: From the OED definition of amateurism: “Quote: 1868 Tomahawk 5 Dec., Amateurism is the curse of the nineteenth century”.

Blogged with Flock

Filed Under: Uncategorized

Archives

Categories

Copyright © 2026 · Magazine Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in